Fluoride: Drinking Water

Department of Health written question – answered on 17th November 2015.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Earl Baldwin of Bewdley Earl Baldwin of Bewdley Crossbench

To ask Her Majesty’s Government, further to the Written Answers on fluoride in drinking water by Lord Prior of Brampton on 21 September (HL1940 and HL2178), what evidential weight they give to ecological analyses which compare health outcomes in a fluoridated area with those in an unfluoridated one.

Photo of Lord Prior of Brampton Lord Prior of Brampton The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health

Ecological studies are used for comparing public health outcomes in populations. This is particularly so where multiple populations can be included, there can be a proper account of other factors that might have affected the recorded levels of disease and where reasonable assurance that the ascertainment of disease or exposure to a factor under study has been the same for all observed populations.

As such, this study design is appropriate for monitoring health outcomes in fluoridated and non-fluoridated populations. As an example of the caution that should be adopted when observing differences between fluoridated and non-fluoridated populations, the authors of the 2014 Public Health England (PHE) health monitoring report, both in the report and in a recent summary in the scientific literature (Young et. al. 2015 which is attached) stressed that, whilst lower levels of renal stones and bladder cancer were observed in fluoridated populations, the ecological design prohibits any conclusions being drawn about a protective role of water fluoridation for these conditions.

Young et al 2015 (PDF Document, 91.02 KB)

Does this answer the above question?

Yes1 person thinks so

No4 people think not

Would you like to ask a question like this yourself? Use our Freedom of Information site.

Annotations

Paul McEvoy
Posted on 18 Nov 2015 7:34 pm (Report this annotation)

"Fluoride poisons enzymes, you don't want to put this substance in the body, Poisoning enzymes is what makes people sick, poisoning enzymes is what kills people. "

James Sumner, Noble prize winner for enzyme chemistry.

Jane Birkby
Posted on 28 Nov 2015 1:12 am (Report this annotation)

I note there is no mention of the prevelance of Hypothyroidism in flouridated areas, or the effect of flouride on the bones, or any of the many other adverse effects caused when this toxin is ingested. Shame on Lord Prior of Brampton for his establishment tow the line reply, backed up by biased science.