We need your support to keep TheyWorkForYou running and make sure people across the UK can continue to hold their elected representatives to account.Donate to our crowdfunder
To ask Her Majesty's Government what information and evidence is available to demonstrate whether there is differential sentencing by the courts of white, black and Asian offenders for similar offences.
The Ministry of Justice Court proceedings database contains information on sentencing and ethnicity. Analysis of these data was reported in Statistics on Race and the Criminal Justice System 2010.
Table 1 below shows the number of persons sentenced for indictable offences at all courts by observed ethnicity, and the average immediate custodial sentence length (ACSL) in months in 2010.
|Table 1: Persons sentenced at all courts for indictable offences by ethnic appearance, England and Wales 2010|
|Average immediate Custodial Sentence Length (months)||14.9||20.8||19.9||19.7||17.6||16.2|
It shows that a higher percentage of those in the black, asian and minority ethnic (BME) groups were sentenced to immediate custody for indictable offences than in the white group in 2010 (white 23 per cent, black 27 per cent, asian 29 per cent and other 42 per cent).
Table 2 shows the average custodial sentence length (ACSL) in 2010 for the 81,536 who were given determinate sentences for indictable offences. It indicates that there are differences in ACSL by ethnic group within offence group.
|Table 2: Average immediate custodial sentence length at all courts by offence group and ethnic appearance, England and Wales 2010|
|Average immediate custodial sentence length (months)|
|Violence against the person||16.8||20.1||23.6||21.8||20.2||17.8|
|Theft and handling stolen goods||3.7||4.5||6.3||7.6||5.1||4.1|
|Fraud and forgery||11.5||9.3||11.7||10.3||11.9||11.0|
|Other (excl motoring offences)||8.3||14.7||16.2||13.3||9.4||9.6|
|Indictable motoring offences||9.9||9.6||9.0||9.2||8.6||9.6|
|All indictable offences||14.9||20.8||19.9||19.7||17.6||16.2|
Note: Average immediate custodial sentence length excludes indeterminate sentences.
Further information on sentencing by ethnic groups for specific offence types can be found in the supplementary tables that accompany Statistics on Race and the Criminal Justice System 2010.
The identification of differences should not be equated with discrimination as there are many reasons why apparent disparities exist. Differences between ethnic groups may occur for a number of reasons including: the mix of crimes committed; the seriousness of the offence; the presence of mitigating or aggravating factors; whether a defendant pleads guilty; or whether the defendant was represented or not. Research by Thomas (2010) for the Ministry of Justice indicated that people from BME backgrounds were more likely to plead not guilty and be tried. A guilty plea can reduce a sentence by up to a third.