Schools

Scottish Executive – in the Scottish Parliament at 2:30 pm on 24th June 1999.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Nicola Sturgeon Nicola Sturgeon Scottish National Party 2:30 pm, 24th June 1999

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has any plans to change the current method of target setting in schools. (S1O-80)

Photo of Sam Galbraith Sam Galbraith Labour

Our guiding principle is that every school should embrace the principle of continuous improvement. Target setting is important and we will work with schools and education authorities to make it as effective as possible.

Photo of Nicola Sturgeon Nicola Sturgeon Scottish National Party

I will take that as a no. Does the minister accept that the current method of target setting in schools has almost no support among teachers, education authorities and parents? In fact, the Scottish Parent Teacher Council has been one of the method's most outspoken critics. Does he further accept that the targets have little or no statistical validity because of their reliance on free school meal entitlement, which is an inadequate measure of the differences in school intake characteristics? Finally, does he accept that if we are to have targets that can assist in raising standards, they must be more sophisticated and bear more relevance to the individual circumstances of schools?

Photo of Sam Galbraith Sam Galbraith Labour

I do not agree with Nicola's first point. The teaching profession has shown support for this method of setting targets. My colleague Peter Peacock was at St Francis Primary School in Niddrie, at which teachers said that the targets were absolutely essential to enhance their school's status.

Once again, I detect the general vein of complaining about things but never coming up with something constructive. Target setting as a principle is not negotiable. What is negotiable is the ways in which target setting can be improved. I look forward to Nicola bringing her suggestions to me.