Wednesday, 19 March 2003
[THE PRESIDING OFFICER opened the meeting at 09:30]
To lead our time for reflection this morning, we welcome the Rev William McFadden, who is the Vice-Rector of Scotus College in Glasgow.
We come to consideration of business motion S1M-4039, in the name of Patricia Ferguson, which sets out a revised business programme. Motion moved, That the Parliament agrees— (a) as a...
The next item of business is the first part of the stage 3 proceedings on the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Bill. For the first part of the proceedings, members should have before...
Amendment 31 is grouped with amendments 32 and 33.
Amendment 33 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 1 is grouped with amendments 2 and 3.
Amendment 4 is grouped with amendments 5 and 6.
Amendment 6 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 273 is grouped with amendments 274, 8, 275 and 276.
Amendment 8 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 275 and 276 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 34 is grouped with amendment 106.
Amendment 70 not moved.
Amendment 107 is grouped with amendments 109 to 112, 143, 146, 149, 150, 153, 154, 159 to 161, 164, 113, 218, 219, 242, 243 and 252 to 271.
Amendments 109 to 112 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 71 not moved.
Amendment 72 not moved.
Amendment 73 not moved.
Amendment 277 is grouped with amendments 278 and 279.
Amendment 280 is grouped with amendments 280 to 287, 304 to 311, 318 to 322 and 734.
Amendment 288 is grouped with amendments 289, 314, 317, 347, 348, 358, 359, 361, 435, 441, 457, 468, 471, 472, 165, 186, 191, 192, 479, 481, 483, 574, 588, 589, 614, 622, 623, 646, 650, 651, 652,...
Amendment 297 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 298 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 299 and 300 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Group 13 is on the suspension of measures authorising detention and other measures. Amendment 301 is grouped with amendments 302, 330, 331, 37 to 55, 144, 145, 147, 148, 151, 152, 166 to 174,...
Amendments 304 to 311 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 15 is on the duties of the mental health officer. Amendment 312 is grouped with amendments 313, 340, 385, 386, 409 and 410.
Amendments 314 to 316 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 317 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 318 to 322 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 323 and 324 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 325 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 326 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 328 and 329 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 330 and 331 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 332 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 333 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 334 to 336 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 17 is on the application for and making of compulsory treatment orders in respect of notification and the right to be heard. Amendment 337 is grouped with amendments 341 and 346.
Group 18 is on proposed care plans, care plans and part 9 care plans. Amendment 338 is grouped with amendments 339, 360 and 482.
Amendment 341 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 20 relates to the time limit for determining applications for compulsory treatment orders in a special case. Amendment 345 is grouped with amendment 754.
For group 21, amendment 114 is in a group on its own.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer, I seek your guidance. Several constituents have reported to me that they are being prevented from entering the Parliament's public gallery this afternoon....
I have a point of order from Mr Russell.
Resumed debate.
We now resume consideration of amendments. Amendment 115 is grouped with amendment 251.
Amendment 347 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 348 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 349 is grouped with amendments 350 to 356.
Amendment 351 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 352 to 356 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 357 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 358 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 359 and 360 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 361 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Group 24 concerns mandatory reviews. Amendment 362 is grouped with amendments 363 to 365, 485 and 486.
Amendment 365 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 395 is grouped with amendments 396 and 532.
Amendments 397 to 408 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 409 and 410 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 411 to 420 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 421 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 422 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 423 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 424 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 425 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 426 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 28 is on the interim extension or variation of a compulsory treatment order. Amendment 427 is grouped with amendments 428 to 430, 432 to 434, 568 to 571 and 573.
Amendments 428 to 430 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 431 to 433 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 434 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 435 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 436 is grouped with amendments 116 to 129 and amendment 131.
Amendments 438 to 440 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 116 to 129 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 132 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 133 is grouped with amendments 134, 135 and 137 to 139.
Amendments 134 to 137 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 138 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 139 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 140 to 142 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 35 is grouped with amendment 36.
Amendment 36 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 441 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 37 to 46 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 47 to 50 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 51 to 55 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 442 is grouped with amendments 443 to 445, 449 to 452, 454 to 456, 458 to 461 and 464 to 467. This group of amendments deals with the application for or making ex proprio motu of...
Amendment 154 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 159 to 162 and 472 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 76 is in a group on its own.
Amendment 474 is in a group on its own.
Amendment 165 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 166 to 171 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 172 to 174, 476 and 175 to 178 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 179 is grouped with amendments 189, 195, 649 and 692.
Amendments 180 to 183, 477, 184, 185 and 478 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 186 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 187 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 188 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 189 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 190 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 191 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 192 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 193 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 194 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 195 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 196 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 479 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 480 is grouped with amendments 484, 487, 488, 561, 575 and 587.
Amendment 483 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 484 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 485 to 487 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 488 to 493 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 494 to 496 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 497 is grouped with amendment 498.
Amendments 499 to 506 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 507 to 511 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 512 to 518 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 519 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 520 to 524 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 525 to 531 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 532 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 533 to 544 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 545 and 546 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 547 to 555 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 556 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 557 to 559 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 560 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 561 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 562 to 565 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 566 is grouped with amendment 572.
Amendment 568 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 569 to 571 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 572 moved—[Malcom Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 573 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 574 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 575 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 576 is grouped with amendments 577 to 585.
Amendments 580 to 585 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 586 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 587 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 588 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 589 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 47 deals with the period in which review of compulsion and restriction orders or hospital and transfer for treatment direction is to be carried out. Amendment 590 is grouped with amendments...
Amendment 592 is grouped with amendment 628.
Amendment 593 is grouped with amendments 595 to 598, 600, 630, 631, 633 to 635, 637 and 643.
Amendment 595 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendments 596 to 600 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 601 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 602 moved—[Malcolm Chisholm]—and agreed to.
Amendment 603 is grouped with amendments 604, 605, 621 and 638 to 641.
Amendment 606 is grouped with amendments 607 to 610, 612 and 642.
Amendment 613 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 614 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 54 is on the effective revocation of compulsion orders or restriction orders. Amendment 615 is grouped with amendment 617.
Amendments 616 and 617 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 618 and 619 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 55 is on recall from conditional discharge. Amendment 620 is in a group on its own.
Amendment 621 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 622 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 623 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 624 to 627 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 628 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 629 to 631 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 632 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 633 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 634 to 637 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 638 to 641 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 642 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 643 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 644 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 646 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 197 to 203 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 204 to 207, 647, 208 and 209 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 210 to 213, 648, 214 and 215 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 649 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendment 113 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Amendments 650 to 653 moved—[Mrs Mary Mulligan]—and agreed to.
Group 57 is on the designation of medical practitioners. Amendment 654 is grouped with amendments 658 and 661.
The next item of business is consideration of six Parliamentary Bureau motions. I ask Euan Robson to move motions S1M-4034 to S1M-4038 and S1M-4042 en bloc. Motions moved, That the Parliament...
Motion moved, That, under Rule 11.2.4 of Standing Orders, decision time on Wednesday 19 March 2003 be taken at 4.52 pm.—[Euan Robson.] Motion agreed to.
There are six questions to be put as a result of today's business. Unless any member objects, I will put the first five questions together, as they are all about the designation of lead...
The final item of business today is a members' business debate on motion S1M-3961, in the name of Jackie Baillie, on reform of charity law. Motion debated, That the Parliament shares the Scottish...
The Scottish Parliament is the national legislature of Scotland, located in Edinburgh. The Parliament consists of 129 members known as MSPs, elected for four-year terms; 73 represent individual geographical constituencies, and 56 are regional representatives.