Did you mean loss green?
Ross Greer: Following on from Bob Doris’s line of questioning, I am struggling to reconcile the stated purpose of the £145 million that was provided this year with the results of the school staff census that the cabinet secretary outlines and COSLA’s statement in the briefing that it sent to MSPs that that money was spent on school staff. I cannot see how that happened when the number of school...
...Gulhane, Sandesh, Hamilton, Rachael, Hoy, Craig, Halcro Johnston, Jamie, Kerr, Liam, Kerr, Stephen, Lumsden, Douglas, McArthur, Liam, McCall, Roz, Mountain, Edward, Mundell, Oliver, Rennie, Willie, Ross, Douglas, Simpson, Graham, Smith, Liz, Stewart, Alexander, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whittle, Brian, Wishart, Beatrice Against: Adam, George, Adam, Karen, Adamson, Clare,...
Ross Greer: Will the member take an intervention?
..., Graeme, Don, Natalie, Doris, Bob, Dornan, James, Dunbar, Jackie, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gibson, Kenneth, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Kidd, Bill, Lochhead, Richard, MacDonald, Gordon, MacGregor, Fulton, Mackay, Gillian, Mackay, Rona,...
..., Kerr, Stephen, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, Lumsden, Douglas, Marra, Michael, McArthur, Liam, McCall, Roz, McNeill, Pauline, Mochan, Carol, Mundell, Oliver, O’Kane, Paul, Rennie, Willie, Ross, Douglas, Smith, Liz, Smyth, Colin, Stewart, Alexander, Sweeney, Paul, Villalba, Mercedes, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whitfield, Martin, Whittle, Brian Against: Adam, George,...
..., Kerr, Stephen, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, Lumsden, Douglas, Marra, Michael, McArthur, Liam, McCall, Roz, McNeill, Pauline, Mochan, Carol, Mundell, Oliver, O’Kane, Paul, Rennie, Willie, Ross, Douglas, Sarwar, Anas, Simpson, Graham, Smith, Liz, Smyth, Colin, Stewart, Alexander, Sweeney, Paul, Villalba, Mercedes, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whitfield, Martin, Whittle,...
..., Golden, Maurice, Gosal, Pam, Greene, Jamie, Gulhane, Sandesh, Hamilton, Rachael, Hoy, Craig, Halcro Johnston, Jamie, Kerr, Liam, Kerr, Stephen, Lumsden, Douglas, McCall, Roz, Mundell, Oliver, Ross, Douglas, Simpson, Graham, Smith, Liz, Stewart, Alexander, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whittle, Brian Against: Adam, George, Adam, Karen, Adamson, Clare, Allan, Alasdair, Arthur,...
Ross Greer: ...high-quality debate on how public money is raised and spent. However, as the convener noted, we are locked into an annual pattern of every sector just demanding more money—a bidding war that grossly oversimplifies how our public finances actually work. Worse than that, it makes it impossible for members of the public to distinguish between deliberate choices that are political, which...
..., McKelvie, Christina, McLennan, Paul, McMillan, Stuart, McNair, Marie, Minto, Jenni, Mountain, Edward, Mundell, Oliver, Nicoll, Audrey, Regan, Ash, Robertson, Angus, Robison, Shona, Roddick, Emma, Ross, Douglas, Smith, Liz, Somerville, Shirley-Anne, Stevenson, Collette, Stewart, Kaukab, Stewart, Kevin, Swinney, John, Thomson, Michelle, Todd, Maree, Torrance, David, Tweed, Evelyn, Webber,...
..., Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, Findlay, Russell, FitzPatrick, Joe, Fraser, Murdo, Gallacher, Meghan, Gibson, Kenneth, Golden, Maurice, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Gray, Neil, Greene, Jamie, Greer, Ross, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Halcro Johnston, Jamie, Kerr, Liam, Kerr, Stephen, Kidd, Bill, Lochhead, Richard, Lumsden, Douglas,...
...Natalie, Doris, Bob, Dornan, James, Dunbar, Jackie, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gibson, Kenneth, Gilruth, Jenny, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Kidd, Bill, Lochhead, Richard, MacDonald, Gordon, MacGregor, Fulton, Mackay, Gillian, Mackay, Rona,...
Division number 1 For: Baker, Claire, Burgess, Ariane, Chapman, Maggie, Choudhury, Foysol, Clark, Katy, Duncan-Glancy, Pam, Grant, Rhoda, Greer, Ross, Griffin, Mark, Harvie, Patrick, Johnson, Daniel, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, Mackay, Gillian, Marra, Michael, McNeill, Pauline, Mochan, Carol, O’Kane, Paul, Ruskell, Mark, Slater, Lorna, Smyth, Colin, Sweeney, Paul, Villalba, Mercedes,...
..., Dunbar, Jackie, Duncan-Glancy, Pam, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gibson, Kenneth, Gilruth, Jenny, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Grant, Rhoda, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Griffin, Mark, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Johnson, Daniel, Kidd, Bill, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, Lochhead, Richard,...
..., Kerr, Stephen, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, Lumsden, Douglas, McArthur, Liam, McCall, Roz, McNeill, Pauline, Mochan, Carol, Mountain, Edward, Mundell, Oliver, O’Kane, Paul, Rennie, Willie, Ross, Douglas, Sarwar, Anas, Simpson, Graham, Smith, Liz, Smyth, Colin, Stewart, Alexander, Sweeney, Paul, Villalba, Mercedes, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whitfield, Martin, Whittle,...
Elizabeth Smith: ...’s upbeat remarks, particularly those in the last paragraph of the statement. It is good to hear his comments about joint working. Can I assume that the cabinet secretary does not agree with Ross Greer’s view? Last Friday, Ross Greer said: “There is nothing green about so-called green freeports. They are a failed and dated Tory gimmick which hands public cash over to multinational...
..., Angela, Dey, Graeme, Don, Natalie, Doris, Bob, Dornan, James, Dunbar, Jackie, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Kidd, Bill, Lochhead, Richard, MacDonald, Gordon, MacGregor, Fulton, Mackay, Gillian, Mackay, Rona,...
Ross Greer: We now have two sets of national qualifications results from years when exams did not take place and pupils were graded based on continuous assessment and the professional judgment of their teachers. In those two years, the attainment gap was considerably narrower than in years when grades were based on high-stakes end-of-term exams. Without pre-empting Professor Hayward’s independent...
...Natalie, Doris, Bob, Dornan, James, Dunbar, Jackie, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gibson, Kenneth, Gilruth, Jenny, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Kidd, Bill, Lochhead, Richard, MacDonald, Gordon, MacGregor, Fulton, Mackay, Gillian, Mackay, Rona,...
..., Dunbar, Jackie, Duncan-Glancy, Pam, Ewing, Annabelle, Ewing, Fergus, Fairlie, Jim, FitzPatrick, Joe, Gibson, Kenneth, Gilruth, Jenny, Gougeon, Mairi, Grahame, Christine, Grant, Rhoda, Gray, Neil, Greer, Ross, Griffin, Mark, Harper, Emma, Harvie, Patrick, Haughey, Clare, Hepburn, Jamie, Hyslop, Fiona, Johnson, Daniel, Kidd, Bill, Lennon, Monica, Leonard, Richard, MacDonald, Gordon,...
..., Gosal, Pam, Greene, Jamie, Gulhane, Sandesh, Hamilton, Rachael, Hoy, Craig, Halcro Johnston, Jamie, Kerr, Liam, Kerr, Stephen, Lumsden, Douglas, McCall, Roz, Mountain, Edward, Mundell, Oliver, Ross, Douglas, Smith, Liz, Stewart, Alexander, Webber, Sue, Wells, Annie, White, Tess, Whittle, Brian Against: Adam, George, Adam, Karen, Adamson, Clare, Allan, Dr Alasdair, Arthur, Tom, Baillie,...