Mr James Lowther: The hon. Member will have to give notice of that question.
Mr James Lowther: The hon. Member had better give notice of that question. It does not arise out of the answer.
Mr James Lowther: That hardly arises out of the question. That is a matter of opinion.
Mr James Lowther: We shall have another opportunity to continue the debate.
Mr James Lowther: informed the House that he had received the following letter relating to the arrest and internment of a Member:
Mr James Lowther: We are now discussing the Army Reserves.
Mr James Lowther: How does that matter arise on this Address? This relates to a, puisne judge, and not to the Lord Chief Justice.
Mr James Lowther: That is rather a strong hypothesis. Had that particular judge not been appointed, one of the other judges would have been appointed, and that would have led to exactly the same Address.
Mr James Lowther: That is not in any way relevant to this Motion.
Mr James Lowther: The hon. Gentleman's criticism is wholly irrelevant.
Mr James Lowther: That is purely a matter for argument. It cannot be dealt with by question and answer.
Mr James Lowther: It is a question which has already been put.
Mr James Lowther: Not answered to the hon. and gallant Member's satisfaction, but it has been answered twice by the learned Attorney-General.
Mr James Lowther: This hardly arises out of this question.
Mr James Lowther: May I point out that if the hon. and gallant Member wants to put a question on general policy to the Attorney-General for Ireland or to anybody else, he ought to give notice of it in the ordinary way, and if it is of a very pressing nature, and he will give notice to me, I will see whether. it can be allowed at the conclusion of questions.
Mr James Lowther: Sir William Davison.
Mr James Lowther: The hon. and gallant Gentleman's tone is not such as commends itself to me.
Mr James Lowther: Will the Noble Lady put her question, without lecturing the House?
Mr James Lowther: That is a question for the Secretary of State for War.
Mr James Lowther: Notice of a question of that kind should have appeared on the Paper.