The Earl of Dundee

Conservative Peer

UK Parliament Profile

💚 Help keep TheyWorkForYou free and independent

For over 20 years, TheyWorkForYou has been making our democracy more transparent and our politicians more accountable.

We need your support to:

  • Hold Power to Account — We highlight what our representatives are doing so they know the public is watching.
  • Keep It Free and Accessible — No paywalls because everyone deserves unbiased information about decisions made on their behalf.
  • Innovate and Go Further — How politics works is always changing and we're always looking for new opportunites to improve things.

We don't want to wait for a better political system to be given to us – we want to work together to make it happen now.

🗣️ Speeches and Debates

  • House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Report (2nd Day) (Continued): Amendment 26 9 Jul 2025

    My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for her remarks. On legislative scrutiny and holding Governments to account, perhaps there may be consensus in three major respects. First, the high standard of the present House in achieving legislative scrutiny should carry on in a reformed House. Secondly, and conversely, if possible, future membership composition ought to be designed to serve that...
  • House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Report (2nd Day) (Continued): Amendment 26 9 Jul 2025

    I was hoping to put this in context; my noble friend Lady Finn in her remarks did just that too, saying that we really want to make sure that we can continue the very high standard of legislative scrutiny of our present House in a reformed House. I will just finish my remarks. As already alleged, these respective portions would provide a good balance for sustaining and carrying on our present...
  • House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Report (2nd Day) (Continued): Amendment 26 9 Jul 2025

    I am grateful to the Leader of the House for her interest. I am not going to be tempted to press to a vote, but if I could possibly finish my remarks, we may be able to round off the context. I am grateful too for the contribution from the Opposition Front Bench and from my noble friend Lady Finn, and within this grouping for the useful amendment from the noble Earl, Lord Devon, on...
  • House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Report (2nd Day) (Continued): Amendment 26 9 Jul 2025

    My Lords, within this grouping, Amendment 26 would enable a review of the impact of this Act on the ability of the House of Lords to scrutinise legislation and hold the Government to account. Your Lordships will agree that the membership composition of a reformed House must sustain and continue the high legislative scrutiny standard of the present House, and thus, conversely, that future...
  • House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill - Report (1st Day) (Continued): Amendment 5 2 Jul 2025

    My Lords, in this grouping I support Amendment 6, proposed by my noble friend Lord Hailsham. Your Lordships will agree that the membership composition of a reformed House must sustain and continue the high legislative scrutiny standard of the present House—and thus, conversely, that future membership composition should be designed to serve this priority aim. If, within the temporal...
  • Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill - Committee (4th Day): Amendment 77 12 Jun 2025

    My Lords, I support strongly this group of amendments. Does the Minister agree that local authorities would very much welcome the positive effects of these constructive amendments? Thereby, local authority education success stories would become more visible and, as my noble friend Lord Lucas has already implied, that visibility in itself would clearly assist further improvement. As indicated...
  • Holocaust Memorial Bill - Report (Continued): Amendment 3 11 Jun 2025

    My Lords, I support both amendments in this group. If the Holocaust Memorial Learning Centre were to be placed in Victoria Tower Gardens, as the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, correctly warns, there is the risk of terrorism attacks, whether by state-sponsored or self-initiated terrorists. As he has indicated, that is because of its proximity to the Palace of Westminster. Thus, in association with...
  • Data (Use and Access) Bill [HL] - Commons Reason: Motion A1 (as an amendment to Motion A) 4 Jun 2025

    My Lords, I join with others in supporting the noble Baroness in exercising her right to insist upon Amendment 49F. Three months after the Government’s own report, this allows Parliament to be informed of the scale of the theft and the loss of revenue to United Kingdom companies, as it also enables a draft Bill on copyright infringement, AI models and transparency of input. Your Lordships...

More of The Earl of Dundee's speeches and debates

✍️ Written Questions and Answers

More of The Earl of Dundee's written questions