Derek Brownlee
Former Conservative MSP for South of Scotland
Former Conservative MSP for South of Scotland
That is a terrifying prospect. Given that we vote in the budget debate in February, I always wondered why we regularly come back to consider such orders. I appreciate that there is the technicality of voting to give additional money to councils around the council tax freeze, but I always wondered why we had debates associated with such orders and whether we were not simply rehearsing old...
I am glad that someone on the Labour benches has finally admitted that the recession happened on that party’s watch, because Labour members have been keen to deny that in previous years. Michael McMahon tells us that the Labour Party has been keen on the council tax freeze, which makes me wonder what Tom McCabe, David Whitton and Malcolm Chisholm were thinking when they voted against the...
Oh—it is underfunded, which I presume is why, in 2009, Mr McMahon said: “The SNP Government is ripping off local councils by £270 million.” Are we to take it that the Labour Party proposal now is that the council tax freeze will be fully funded if it gets £270 million per year extra? It appears that Labour members here, like their masters in London, are happy to make spending...
Former Conservative MSP for South of Scotland
Entered the Scottish Parliament on 22 June 2005 — Appointed, regional replacement
Left the Scottish Parliament on 23 March 2011 — Election
Please note that numbers do not measure quality. Also, representatives may do other things not currently covered by this site. More about this
Note for journalists and researchers: The data on this page may be used freely, on condition that TheyWorkForYou.com is cited as the source.
This data was produced by TheyWorkForYou from a variety of sources. Voting information from Public Whip.