Part of Great British Energy Bill - Committee (3rd Day) – in the House of Lords at 7:15 pm on 13 January 2025.
My Lords, I support the amendments in my name and those of my noble friends Lady Bloomfield, Lord Trenchard and Lord Effingham. They aim to ensure that the proposed entity, Great British Energy, operates in a manner that aligns with fiscal responsibility, transparency, accountability and the overarching national interest.
Amendment 78, tabled by my noble friend Lady Bloomfield, mandates the reinvestment of all profits back into the company. The reinvestment question is a good test of what GBE is about and its future performance. As I said, GBE is de facto a permanent capital investment vehicle that will be deploying capital in illiquid minority stakes. It is very unlikely that it will ever be able to dispose of those and realise a lot of liquidity, so at best it will deliver some dividends. If it did, it would be best for it to be reinvested, ensuring that the £8.3 billion is the maximum commitment for taxpayers.
My Amendment 79 in my name stipulates that Great British Energy must not invest in projects that are reliant on government subsidies. GBE is already structured as a crowding-in investment, which means that it is likely to take more risk and accept lower returns than the private sector. This is what the mandate of “facilitate, encourage and participate” means to me. There is nothing wrong with that, but the private sector and foreign funds should be attracted to the GB partnership for that reason. Therefore, I see no reason to pile in and give the private capital two bites of the cherry by allowing it to work with GBE with government subsidies.
I spoke enough about Amendment 80 earlier. Amendment 81 builds on it with a firm measure of accountability. By requiring independent third-party evaluations of GBE’s investments, we introduce an essential safeguard against conflict of interest and political interference. Transparency and objectivity in evaluating investments are paramount, especially when the risk of poor decision-making with public funds looms large. As your Lordships know, I am particularly concerned by the lack of detail and definition of investment process and framework within GBE, at least at this stage. I believe that the Minister has taken good note of my concern about the lack of precision on an investment committee.
Finally, Amendment 82 limits Great British Energy’s investment to UK-registered companies. The purpose of this entity, as set out by the Government, is to bolster Britain’s energy security and our national economy. Investing in foreign-registered companies undermines that goal. We must ensure that any investment of public money supports British jobs, British innovation and British interests. This amendment ensures that GBE prioritises domestic enterprises, strengthening the UK’s energy sector and reducing dependency on foreign entities.
I will remind the House of the holy grails that I think we want to achieve with GBE. Number one is energy security; number two is energy sovereignty; number three is economic growth; and number four is low costs for bills and more employment. Indeed, we do not want GBE to outsource, be it our energy security, sovereignty or supply chains. We know it is an incredibly difficult topic because, as a country, we are ahead on decarbonisation, but we are behind in terms of ownership of our own infrastructure. We are also behind in terms of supply chains and we are behind on production of cable, wind turbines and other technology. Therefore, we have a lot of work to do in this area and I think it will be an extremely difficult topic because of supply chains, China dominance and the fact that we are behind on infrastructure and technology.
All these amendments share a common theme: safeguarding taxpayer money, ensuring operational transparency and prioritising the interests of the British people. Conservatives believe in the power of the private sector and market-led solutions and, where state intervention occurs, as in this case, oversight is extremely important. We urge the Government to accept these amendments and commit to ensuring that GBE operates as a responsible, efficient and transparent entity.