Lord Roborough:

Moved by Lord Roborough

51: Leave out Clause 10Member’s explanatory statementThis amendment would prevent consumers in England from being charged higher water bills to cover any losses incurred by the Government as a result of the Secretary of State’s decision to make a special administration order.

My Lords, the Minister said that His Majesty’s Government do not expect to use these powers in Clause 10. I struggle to believe that any noble Lord listening to the noble Baroness describe socialising these losses across consumers can feel comfortable, however unlikely it is. If the clause is not to be used, I would like to test the opinion of the House on whether it should stand part.

Ayes 36, Noes 89.

Amendment 51 disagreed.

Clause 11: Modification by Welsh Ministers of water company’s appointment conditions etc to recover losses

Amendment 52 not moved.

Amendments 53 to 59 not moved.

Clause 13: Extent, commencement, transitional provision and short title