Welfare Reform Bill — Report (1st Day) (Continued)

Part of the debate – in the House of Lords at 5:00 pm on 22 October 2009.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Baroness Thomas of Winchester Baroness Thomas of Winchester Spokesperson for Work and Pensions 5:00, 22 October 2009

My Lords, I thank the Minister for that reply and my noble friend Lord Kirkwood for his passionate speech in support of my amendment.

It is perhaps ironic that, of all the complications in the benefits system, the one benefit that is not complicated to those who receive it and is well understood is income support—yet this is the one that is to be abolished. I understand that the Minister has said that it will not be abolished until no one needs it, so it could be a structure with no one hanging off it. However, it has not convinced all those who advise us and who deal with the most complex problems. It is bad practice. We do not want future Governments to abolish something before its replacement is clear and in place.

The Minister and the House will be pleased to know that at this hour on a Thursday afternoon it would not be sensible to vote. Although there are some outside who would like us to, we would not get very far. I thank the Minister for his further remarks and beg leave to withdraw the amendment.

Amendment 34 withdrawn.

Clause 8 : Power to direct claimant to undertake specific work-related activity

Amendment 35 not moved.

Amendment 36

Moved by Lord McKenzie of Luton

36: Clause 8, page 14, line 8, at end insert—

"(1A) But a direction under subsection (1) may not specify medical or surgical treatment as the only activity which, in any person's case, is to be regarded as being work-related activity."

Amendment 36 agreed.

Amendment 37

Moved by Baroness Meacher

37: Clause 8, page 14, line 15, at end insert—

"(3) Before the Secretary of State gives a direction under subsection (1) to a person with a fluctuating condition he must assess that person's condition over a period of time. For the purposes of this section a "fluctuating condition" is one in which the period of illness resulting in limitations associated with the physical or mental condition of a person are episodic in nature."