Criminal Justice: Women

Part of the debate – in the House of Lords at 5:18 pm on 29 June 2006.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Baroness Scotland of Asthal Baroness Scotland of Asthal Minister of State (Criminal Justice and Offender Management), Home Office, Minister of State (Home Office) (Criminal Justice and Offender Management) 5:18, 29 June 2006

My Lords, I understand the pain and difficulty that Pauline Campbell may be in, so I will rephrase that and say that it is not a just assessment of the conditions in prisons.

The noble Baroness, Lady Howe, rightly emphasised the issue of children and Every Child Matters, and I strongly agree with her. The work that we are doing in this area is not simply dependent on what we are doing in prisons; it is what we are doing on education, with Every Child Matters and Sure Start. All those things will contribute to an improvement of the way that we respond.

What we are doing to support women who are domestic violence victims is immensely important. The programmes of specialist domestic violence courts now have tremendous results, and there has been a clear improvement in the number of women who start cases and are able to go right the way through. There is an improvement in the number of women who are now able to get orders that keep them protected. In the areas where specialist domestic violence courts operate, we do not have people coming back. The numbers of women who are killed by their partners or ex-partners are going down. Before we started specialist domestic violence courts, 120 women died every year, which is two to three women a week. Now it has gone down to 100, and it looks as if it is going lower.

The number of incidents of domestic violence may also be reducing although, with the grace of God, the numbers who have the courage to report it are going up. These are very positive things. There is much work to do, and I will obviously listen and look very carefully at the report that my noble friend Lady Corston will be issuing in December. This issue is not closed. I know from those who sit behind me, not least my noble friend Lord Acton, that it will not be closed until he and a number of other noble Lords get their way.

Annotations

Pauline Campbell
Posted on 5 Aug 2006 1:39 am (Report this annotation)

On the contrary, it IS a just assessment of prisons. The words "mediaeval and barbaric" are an apt description of the following: (i) HMP Brockhill - prison inspectorate report published 17.05.05: "night sanitation system grossly inadequate, with women on occasions reduced to using plastic bags and rubbish bins"; (ii) HMP Holloway - serious infestations of mice, pigeons and insects, reported in The Daily Telegraph, 30.03.05; (iii) HMP Styal, reported in The Guardian, 01.02.06: "Barbaric trips endured by pregnant prisoners"; (iv) HMP Bullwood Hall, reported in The Guardian, 01.06.06: "End degrading slopping out, says prisons watchdog". [Bereaved mother of teenager who died in the so-called care of HMP & YOI Styal, Cheshire, 2003]

Pauline Campbell
Posted on 9 Jan 2007 10:02 pm (Report this annotation)

Baroness Scotland said: "I understand the pain and difficulty Pauline Campbell may be in ..." Firstly, I think we can delete the word "may". Secondly, and with respect, the Prisons Minister does NOT understand my pain and difficulty. In fact, my "pain and difficulty" is exacerbated by the fact that her Department (Home Office) has failed to apologise for my daughter's death, a fact which is highlighted in the following report:

"Shameful Admission" The Guardian 27 September 2006 http://society.guardian.co.uk/crimeandpunishment/story/0,,18...

My earlier comment was logged on 05.08.06, prior to the Home Office (shameful) admission.

This comment is logged on 09.01.07 (four months after The Guardian report), and I regret to say the apology is still outstanding.

domestic violence

violence occurring within the family