Division number 4
Queen's Speech — Devolution of Tax Raising and Borrowing Powers to the Welsh Government
A majority of MPs disagreed and voted against devolving tax raising, and borrowing, powers to the Welsh Government.
Want to understand more about this vote? Read the debate that it was part of.
Aye: 237 MPs
No: 316 MPs
Ayes: A-Z by last name
- Diane Abbott Labour
- Debbie Abrahams Labour
- Bob Ainsworth Labour
- Douglas Alexander Labour
- Heidi Alexander Labour
- Rushanara Ali Labour
- Graham Allen Labour
- David Anderson Labour
- Jon Ashworth Labour
- Adrian Bailey Labour
- William Bain Labour
- Edward Balls Labour
- Gordon Banks Labour
- Kevin Barron Labour
- Hugh Bayley Labour
- Margaret Beckett Labour
- Anne Begg Labour
- Hilary Benn Labour
- Luciana Berger Labour
- Clive Betts Labour
- Roberta Blackman-Woods Labour
- Hazel Blears Labour
- Tom Blenkinsop Labour
- Paul Blomfield Labour
- Ben Bradshaw Labour
- Kevin Brennan Labour
- Lyn Brown Labour
- Russell Brown Labour
- Nick Brown Labour
- Chris Bryant Labour
- Karen Buck Labour
- Richard Burden Labour
- Andy Burnham Labour
- Liam Byrne Labour
- Alan Campbell Labour
- Martin Caton Labour
- Jenny Chapman Labour
- Katy Clark Labour
- Tom Clarke Labour
- Ann Clwyd Labour
- Vernon Coaker Labour
- Ann Coffey Labour
- Michael Connarty Labour
- Yvette Cooper Labour
- Rosie Cooper Labour
- Jeremy Corbyn Labour
- David Crausby Labour
- Mary Creagh Labour
- Stella Creasy Labour
- Jon Cruddas Labour
- John Cryer Labour
- Tony Cunningham Labour
- Jim Cunningham Labour
- Alex Cunningham Labour
- Margaret Curran Labour
- Nicholas Dakin Labour
- Alistair Darling Labour
- Wayne David Labour
- Ian Davidson Labour
- Geraint Davies Labour
- John Denham Labour
- Frank Dobson Labour
- Nigel Dodds DUP
- Brian H Donohoe Labour
- Frank Doran Labour
- Stephen Doughty Labour
- Jim Dowd Labour
- Gemma Doyle Labour
- Jack Dromey Labour
- Mark Durkan Social Democratic and Labour Party
- Angela Eagle Labour
- Maria Eagle Labour
- Jonathan Edwards Plaid Cymru
- Clive Efford Labour
- Julie Elliott Labour
- Louise Ellman Labour
- Bill Esterson Labour
- Chris Evans Labour
- Paul Farrelly Labour
- Frank Field Labour
- Jim Fitzpatrick Labour
- Rob Flello Labour
- Caroline Flint Labour
- Yvonne Fovargue Labour
- Hywel Francis Labour
- Mike Gapes Labour
- Barry Gardiner Labour
- Sheila Gilmore Labour
- Pat Glass Labour
- Mary Glindon Labour
- Roger Godsiff Labour
- Paul Goggins Labour
- Helen Goodman Labour
- Tom Greatrex Labour
- Kate Green Labour
- Lilian Greenwood Labour
- Nia Griffith Labour
- Andrew Gwynne Labour
- Peter Hain Labour
- Fabian Hamilton Labour
- David Hamilton Labour
- David Hanson Labour
- Harriet Harman Labour
- Tom Harris Labour
- John Healey Labour
- Mark Hendrick Labour
- Stephen Hepburn Labour
- Meg Hillier Labour
- Julie Hilling Labour
- Margaret Hodge Labour
- Sharon Hodgson Labour
- Kate Hoey Labour
- Jimmy Hood Labour
- Kelvin Hopkins Labour
- George Howarth Labour
- Tristram Hunt Labour
- Huw Irranca-Davies Labour
- Glenda Jackson Labour
- Cathy Jamieson Labour
- Dan Jarvis Labour
- Alan Johnson Labour
- Diana R. Johnson Labour
- Kevan Jones Labour
- Graham Jones Labour
- Susan Elan Jones Labour
- Helen Jones Labour
- Tessa Jowell Labour
- Gerald Kaufman Labour
- Barbara Keeley Labour
- Sadiq Khan Labour
- David Lammy Labour
- Ian Lavery Labour
- Mark Lazarowicz Labour
- Chris Leslie Labour
- Emma Lewell-Buck Labour
- Ivan Lewis Labour
- Elfyn Llwyd Plaid Cymru
- Andrew Love Labour
- Ian Lucas Labour
- Caroline Lucas Green
- Angus MacNeil Scottish National Party
- Fiona Mactaggart Labour
- Khalid Mahmood Labour
- Shabana Mahmood Labour
- Seema Malhotra Labour
- John Mann Labour
- Gordon Marsden Labour
- Steve McCabe Labour
- Michael McCann Labour
- Kerry McCarthy Labour
- Gregg McClymont Labour
- William McCrea DUP
- Siobhain McDonagh Labour
- Andy McDonald Labour
- Pat McFadden Labour
- Alison McGovern Labour
- Jim McGovern Labour
- Anne McGuire Labour
- Ann McKechin Labour
- Iain McKenzie Labour
- Catherine McKinnell Labour
- Michael Meacher Labour
- Alan Meale Labour
- Ian Mearns Labour
- Ed Miliband Labour
- Andrew Miller Labour
- Madeleine Moon Labour
- Jessica Morden Labour
- Graeme Morrice Labour
- Grahame Morris Labour
- George Mudie Labour
- Meg Munn Labour
- Jim Murphy Labour
- Paul Murphy Labour
- Ian Murray Labour
- Lisa Nandy Labour
- Pamela Nash Labour
- Fiona O'Donnell Labour
- Chi Onwurah Labour
- Albert Owen Labour
- Teresa Pearce Labour
- Bridget Phillipson Labour
- Steve Pound Labour
- Yasmin Qureshi Labour
- Nick Raynsford Labour
- Steve Reed Labour
- Jamie Reed Labour
- Emma Reynolds Labour
- Jonathan Reynolds Labour
- Linda Riordan Labour
- Angus Robertson Scottish National Party
- John Robertson Labour
- Geoffrey Robinson Labour
- Steve Rotheram Labour
- Frank Roy Labour
- Lindsay Roy Labour
- Chris Ruane Labour
- Joan Ruddock Labour
- Anas Sarwar Labour
- Andy Sawford Labour
- Virendra Sharma Labour
- Barry Sheerman Labour
- Jim Sheridan Labour
- David Simpson DUP
- Dennis Skinner Labour
- Andrew Slaughter Labour
- Owen Smith Labour
- Nick Smith Labour
- Andrew Smith Labour
- John Spellar Labour
- Jack Straw Labour
- Graham Stringer Labour
- Gerry Sutcliffe Labour
- Mark Tami Labour
- Gareth Thomas Labour
- Emily Thornberry Labour
- Stephen Timms Labour
- Jon Trickett Labour
- Karl Turner Labour
- Stephen Twigg Labour
- Valerie Vaz Labour
- Keith Vaz Labour
- Joan Walley Labour
- Tom Watson Labour
- Dave Watts Labour
- Michael Weir Scottish National Party
- Alan Whitehead Labour
- Chris Williamson Labour
- Phil Wilson Labour
- Sammy Wilson DUP
- David Winnick Labour
- Rosie Winterton Labour
- Mike Wood Labour
- John Woodcock Labour
- Shaun Woodward Labour
- Iain Wright Labour
- David Wright Labour
Tellers
- Stewart Hosie Scottish National Party
- Pete Wishart Scottish National Party
Nos: A-Z by last name
- Nigel Adams Conservative
- Adam Afriyie Conservative
- Peter Aldous Conservative
- Danny Alexander Liberal Democrat
- Sir David Amess Conservative
- Stuart Andrew Conservative
- Richard Bacon Conservative
- Norman Baker Liberal Democrat
- Steven Baker Conservative
- Tony Baldry Conservative
- Harriett Baldwin Conservative
- Stephen Barclay Conservative
- Gregory Barker Conservative
- John Baron Conservative
- Gavin Barwell Conservative
- Guto Bebb Conservative
- Alan Beith Liberal Democrat
- Henry Bellingham Conservative
- Richard Benyon Conservative
- Paul Beresford Conservative
- Andrew Bingham Conservative
- Brian Binley Conservative
- Gordon Birtwistle Liberal Democrat
- Nicola Blackwood Conservative
- Nicholas Boles Conservative
- Peter Bone Conservative
- Graham Brady Conservative
- Tom Brake Liberal Democrat
- Angie Bray Conservative
- Andrew Bridgen Conservative
- Steve Brine Conservative
- James Brokenshire Conservative
- Annette Brooke Liberal Democrat
- Jeremy Browne Liberal Democrat
- Fiona Bruce Conservative
- Robert Buckland Conservative
- Aidan Burley Conservative
- Simon Burns Conservative
- Conor Burns Conservative
- David Burrowes Conservative
- Paul Burstow Liberal Democrat
- Lorely Burt Liberal Democrat
- Alistair Burt Conservative
- Dan Byles Conservative
- Vincent Cable Liberal Democrat
- Alun Cairns Conservative
- Menzies Campbell Liberal Democrat
- Neil Carmichael Conservative
- Douglas Carswell Conservative
- Bill Cash Conservative
- Rehman Chishti Conservative
- Christopher Chope Conservative
- James Clappison Conservative
- Greg Clark Conservative
- Kenneth Clarke Conservative
- Nick Clegg Liberal Democrat
- Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative
- Therese Coffey Conservative
- Geoffrey Cox Conservative
- Stephen Crabb Conservative
- Michael Crockart Liberal Democrat
- Tracey Crouch Conservative
- Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
- Glyn Davies Conservative
- Philip Davies Conservative
- David Davies Conservative
- David Davis Conservative
- Nick de Bois Conservative
- Caroline Dinenage Conservative
- Stephen Dorrell Conservative
- Nadine Dorries Conservative
- Jackie Doyle-Price Conservative
- Richard Drax Conservative
- James Duddridge Conservative
- Alan Duncan Conservative
- Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
- Philip Dunne Conservative
- Michael Ellis Conservative
- Jane Ellison Conservative
- Tobias Ellwood Conservative
- Charlie Elphicke Conservative
- George Eustice Conservative
- Graham Evans Conservative
- Jonathan Evans Conservative
- David Evennett Conservative
- Michael Fabricant Conservative
- Michael Fallon Conservative
- Tim Farron Liberal Democrat
- Mark Field Conservative
- Paul Flynn Labour
- Don Foster Liberal Democrat
- Liam Fox Conservative
- Mark Francois Conservative
- Mike Freer Conservative
- Lorraine Fullbrook Conservative
- Richard Fuller Conservative
- Roger Gale Conservative
- Mark Garnier Conservative
- Edward Garnier Conservative
- David Gauke Conservative
- Andrew George Liberal Democrat
- Nick Gibb Conservative
- John Glen Conservative
- Zac Goldsmith Conservative
- Robert Goodwill Conservative
- Richard Graham Conservative
- Helen Grant Conservative
- James Gray Conservative
- Chris Grayling Conservative
- Damian Green Conservative
- Dominic Grieve Conservative
- Andrew Griffiths Conservative
- Ben Gummer Conservative
- Sam Gyimah Conservative
- William Hague Conservative
- Robert Halfon Conservative
- Duncan Hames Liberal Democrat
- Philip Hammond Conservative
- Stephen Hammond Conservative
- Matthew Hancock Conservative
- Greg Hands Conservative
- Mark Harper Conservative
- Richard Harrington Conservative
- Rebecca Harris Conservative
- Simon Hart Conservative
- Nick Harvey Liberal Democrat
- Alan Haselhurst Conservative
- John Hayes Conservative
- Oliver Heald Conservative
- David Heath Liberal Democrat
- Chris Heaton-Harris Conservative
- John Hemming Liberal Democrat
- Gordon Henderson Conservative
- Charles Hendry Conservative
- Nick Herbert Conservative
- Damian Hinds Conservative
- Mark Hoban Conservative
- George Hollingbery Conservative
- Philip Hollobone Conservative
- Kris Hopkins Conservative
- Martin Horwood Liberal Democrat
- Gerald Howarth Conservative
- John Howell Conservative
- Simon Hughes Liberal Democrat
- Jeremy Hunt Conservative
- Julian Huppert Liberal Democrat
- Nick Hurd Conservative
- Stewart Jackson Conservative
- Margot James Conservative
- Sajid Javid Conservative
- Bernard Jenkin Conservative
- Jo Johnson Conservative
- Gareth Johnson Conservative
- Andrew Jones Conservative
- David Jones Conservative
- Marcus Jones Conservative
- Daniel Kawczynski Conservative
- Chris Kelly Conservative
- Charles Kennedy Liberal Democrat
- Simon Kirby Conservative
- Greg Knight Conservative
- Kwasi Kwarteng Conservative
- Eleanor Laing Conservative
- Norman Lamb Liberal Democrat
- Mark Lancaster Conservative
- Andrew Lansley Conservative
- Pauline Latham Conservative
- David Laws Liberal Democrat
- Andrea Leadsom Conservative
- Phillip Lee Conservative
- Jessica Lee Conservative
- John Leech Liberal Democrat
- Jeremy Lefroy Conservative
- Edward Leigh Conservative
- Charlotte Leslie Conservative
- Oliver Letwin Conservative
- Julian Lewis Conservative
- Brandon Lewis Conservative
- Ian Liddell-Grainger Conservative
- David Lidington Conservative
- Stephen Lloyd Liberal Democrat
- Jonathan Lord Conservative
- Tim Loughton Conservative
- Peter Luff Conservative
- Karen Lumley Conservative
- Mary Macleod Conservative
- Anne Main Conservative
- Francis Maude Conservative
- Theresa May Conservative
- Paul Maynard Conservative
- Karl McCartney Conservative
- Jason McCartney Conservative
- Anne McIntosh Conservative
- Stephen McPartland Conservative
- Esther McVey Conservative
- Mark Menzies Conservative
- Patrick Mercer Conservative
- Stephen Metcalfe Conservative
- Maria Miller Conservative
- Nigel Mills Conservative
- Anne Milton Conservative
- Andrew Mitchell Conservative
- Michael Moore Liberal Democrat
- Nicky Morgan Conservative
- David Morris Conservative
- James Morris Conservative
- Stephen Mosley Conservative
- David Mowat Conservative
- Greg Mulholland Liberal Democrat
- David Mundell Conservative
- Tessa Munt Liberal Democrat
- Andrew Murrison Conservative
- Bob Neill Conservative
- Brooks Newmark Conservative
- Caroline Nokes Conservative
- Jesse Norman Conservative
- David Nuttall Conservative
- Stephen O'Brien Conservative
- Matthew Offord Conservative
- Eric Ollerenshaw Conservative
- Guy Opperman Conservative
- George Osborne Conservative
- Richard Ottaway Conservative
- James Paice Conservative
- Neil Parish Conservative
- Priti Patel Conservative
- Owen Paterson Conservative
- Mark Pawsey Conservative
- John Penrose Conservative
- Andrew Percy Conservative
- Stephen Phillips Conservative
- Eric Pickles Conservative
- Christopher Pincher Conservative
- Daniel Poulter Conservative
- John Pugh Liberal Democrat
- Dominic Raab Conservative
- John Randall Conservative
- Mark Reckless Conservative
- John Redwood Conservative
- Jacob Rees-Mogg Conservative
- Alan Reid Liberal Democrat
- Malcolm Rifkind Conservative
- Andrew Robathan Conservative
- Laurence Robertson Conservative
- Hugh Robertson Conservative
- Dan Rogerson Liberal Democrat
- Andrew Rosindell Conservative
- Amber Rudd Conservative
- Bob Russell Liberal Democrat
- David Rutley Conservative
- Adrian Sanders Liberal Democrat
- Laura Sandys Conservative
- Lee Scott Conservative
- Andrew Selous Conservative
- Grant Shapps Conservative
- Alok Sharma Conservative
- Alec Shelbrooke Conservative
- Richard Shepherd Conservative
- Keith Simpson Conservative
- Chris Skidmore Conservative
- Robert Smith Liberal Democrat
- Chloe Smith Conservative
- Henry Smith Conservative
- Julian Smith Conservative
- Nicholas Soames Conservative
- Anna Soubry Conservative
- Mark Spencer Conservative
- John Stanley Conservative
- Andrew Stephenson Conservative
- John Stevenson Conservative
- Rory Stewart Conservative
- Iain Stewart Conservative
- Gary Streeter Conservative
- Mel Stride Conservative
- Graham Stuart Conservative
- Andrew Stunell Liberal Democrat
- Julian Sturdy Conservative
- Desmond Swayne Conservative
- Jo Swinson Liberal Democrat
- Hugo Swire Conservative
- Robert Syms Conservative
- Peter Tapsell Conservative
- Mike Thornton Liberal Democrat
- John Thurso Liberal Democrat
- Justin Tomlinson Conservative
- David Tredinnick Conservative
- Elizabeth Truss Conservative
- Andrew Turner Conservative
- Andrew Tyrie Conservative
- Paul Uppal Conservative
- Ed Vaizey Conservative
- Shailesh Vara Conservative
- Martin Vickers Conservative
- Theresa Villiers Conservative
- Charles Walker Conservative
- Robin Walker Conservative
- Ben Wallace Conservative
- Robert Walter Conservative
- David Ward Liberal Democrat
- Angela Watkinson Conservative
- Steve Webb Liberal Democrat
- James Wharton Conservative
- Heather Wheeler Conservative
- Chris White Conservative
- Craig Whittaker Conservative
- John Whittingdale Conservative
- Bill Wiggin Conservative
- David Willetts Conservative
- Gavin Williamson Conservative
- Rob Wilson Conservative
- Sarah Wollaston Conservative
- Jeremy Wright Conservative
- Simon Wright Liberal Democrat
- Tim Yeo Conservative
- George Young Conservative
- Nadhim Zahawi Conservative
Tellers
- Karen Bradley Conservative
- Mark Hunter Liberal Democrat
Absent: 93 MPs
Absents: A-Z by last name
- James Arbuthnot Conservative
- Ian Austin Labour
- Joe Benton Labour
- John Bercow Speaker
- Jake Berry Conservative
- Bob Blackman Conservative
- David Blunkett Labour
- Crispin Blunt Conservative
- Peter Bottomley Conservative
- Julian Brazier Conservative
- Gordon Brown Labour
- Malcolm Bruce Liberal Democrat
- David Cameron Conservative
- Ronnie Campbell Labour
- Gregory Campbell DUP
- Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
- Sarah Champion Labour
- Damian Collins Conservative
- Oliver Colvile Conservative
- Simon Danczuk Labour
- Gloria De Piero Labour
- Jonathan Djanogly Conservative
- Jim Dobbin Labour
- Thomas Docherty Labour
- Pat Doherty Sinn Féin
- Jeffrey M. Donaldson DUP
- Michael Dugher Labour
- Natascha Engel Labour
- Nigel Evans Conservative
- Lynne Featherstone Liberal Democrat
- George Freeman Conservative
- George Galloway Respect
- Stephen Gilbert Liberal Democrat
- Michelle Gildernew Sinn Féin
- Dame Cheryl Gillan Conservative
- Michael Gove Conservative
- Justine Greening Conservative
- Mike Hancock Liberal Democrat
- Dai Havard Labour
- Sylvia Hermon Independent
- David Heyes Labour
- Adam Holloway Conservative
- Lindsay Hoyle Labour
- Siân James Labour
- Eric Joyce Labour
- Liz Kendall Labour
- Peter Lilley Conservative
- Naomi Long Alliance
- Jack Lopresti Conservative
- Paul Maskey Sinn Féin
- Alasdair McDonnell Social Democratic and Labour Party
- John Martin McDonnell Labour
- Patrick McLoughlin Conservative
- Austin Mitchell Labour
- Francie Molloy Sinn Féin
- Penny Mordaunt Conservative
- Anne Marie Morris Conservative
- Conor Murphy Sinn Féin
- Sheryll Murray Conservative
- Sarah Newton Conservative
- Sandra Osborne Labour
- Ian Paisley Jnr DUP
- Mike Penning Conservative
- Toby Perkins Labour
- Claire Perry Conservative
- Lucy Powell Labour
- Dawn Primarolo Labour
- Mark Prisk Conservative
- Mark Pritchard Conservative
- Simon Reevell Conservative
- Rachel Reeves Labour
- Margaret Ritchie Social Democratic and Labour Party
- David Ruffley Conservative
- Alison Seabeck Labour
- Jim Shannon DUP
- Gavin Shuker Labour
- Mark Simmonds Conservative
- Angela Smith Labour
- Caroline Spelman Conservative
- Bob Stewart Conservative
- Gisela Stuart Labour
- Ian Swales Liberal Democrat
- Sarah Teather Liberal Democrat
- Edward Timpson Conservative
- Derek Twigg Labour
- Chuka Umunna Labour
- Mike Weatherley Conservative
- Eilidh Whiteford Scottish National Party
- Stephen Williams Liberal Democrat
- Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
- Mark Williams Liberal Democrat
- Roger Williams Liberal Democrat
- Jennifer Willott Liberal Democrat