Clause 47 - Removal of exemption for private school fees: 3 Mar 2025: House of Commons debates

Division number 111

Amendment proposed: 67, page 53, line 30, leave out clause 47.—(James Wild.)

This amendment removes Clause 47, which removes the VAT exemption for private school fees.

Question put, That the amendment be made.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 3 March 2025, c104)

Aye: 165 MPs

No: 345 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Jim Allister Traditional Unionist Voice
Gideon Amos Liberal Democrat
Stuart Anderson Conservative (proxy vote cast by Gagan Mohindra)
Lee Anderson Reform UK
Stuart Andrew Conservative
Steffan Aquarone Liberal Democrat
Victoria Atkins Conservative
Josh Babarinde Liberal Democrat
Gareth Bacon Conservative
Harriett Baldwin Conservative
Steve Barclay Conservative
Peter Bedford Conservative
Alison Bennett Liberal Democrat
Saqib Bhatti Conservative
Bob Blackman Conservative
Sarah Bool Conservative
Andrew Bowie Conservative
Aphra Brandreth Conservative
Suella Braverman Conservative
Alex Brewer Liberal Democrat
Jessica Brown-Fuller Liberal Democrat
Alex Burghart Conservative
Gregory Campbell DUP
Charlotte Cane Liberal Democrat
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
David Chadwick Liberal Democrat (proxy vote cast by Will Forster)
Wendy Chamberlain Liberal Democrat
Danny Chambers Liberal Democrat
James Cleverly Conservative
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative
Lewis Cocking Conservative
Chris Coghlan Liberal Democrat
Victoria Collins Liberal Democrat
Daisy Cooper Liberal Democrat
John Cooper Conservative
Alberto Costa Conservative
Claire Coutinho Conservative (proxy vote cast by Joy Morrissey)
Harriet Cross Conservative
Adam Dance Liberal Democrat
Steve Darling Liberal Democrat
Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
Gareth Davies Conservative
Mims Davies Conservative
David Davis Conservative
Charlie Dewhirst Conservative
Lee Dillon Liberal Democrat
Caroline Dinenage Conservative
Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
Sarah Dyke Liberal Democrat
Luke Evans Conservative
Nigel Farage Reform UK
Tim Farron Liberal Democrat
Richard Foord Liberal Democrat
Will Forster Liberal Democrat
Peter Fortune Conservative
Ashley Fox Conservative
Mark Francois Conservative
Zöe Franklin Liberal Democrat
Louie French Conservative
Richard Fuller Conservative
Roger Gale Conservative
Mark Garnier Conservative
Andrew George Liberal Democrat
Sarah Gibson Liberal Democrat (proxy vote cast by Will Forster)
Rachel Gilmour Liberal Democrat
Helen Grant Conservative
Sarah Green Liberal Democrat
Andrew Griffith Conservative
Alison Griffiths Conservative
Monica Harding Liberal Democrat
Rebecca Harris Conservative
Pippa Heylings Liberal Democrat
Damian Hinds Conservative
Simon Hoare Conservative
Wera Hobhouse Liberal Democrat
Richard Holden Conservative
Kevin Hollinrake Conservative
Nigel Huddleston Conservative
Neil Hudson Conservative
Adnan Hussain Independent
Christine Jardine Liberal Democrat
Liz Jarvis Liberal Democrat
Bernard Jenkin Conservative
Robert Jenrick Conservative
Dr Caroline Johnson Conservative
Clive Jones Liberal Democrat
Alicia Kearns Conservative (proxy vote cast by Joy Morrissey)
Paul Kohler Liberal Democrat
Danny Kruger Conservative
John Lamont Conservative
Edward Leigh Conservative
Julian Lewis Conservative
Julia Lopez Conservative
Rupert Lowe Reform UK
James MacCleary Liberal Democrat
Angus MacDonald Liberal Democrat
Ben Maguire Liberal Democrat
Alan Mak Conservative
Kit Malthouse Conservative
Brian Mathew Liberal Democrat
Jerome Mayhew Conservative
Charlie Maynard Liberal Democrat
Esther McVey Conservative
Calum Miller Liberal Democrat
John Milne Liberal Democrat
Gagan Mohindra Conservative
Robbie Moore Conservative
Edward Morello Liberal Democrat
Helen Morgan Liberal Democrat
Tom Morrison Liberal Democrat (proxy vote cast by Will Forster)
Joy Morrissey Conservative
Wendy Morton Conservative
Kieran Mullan Conservative
Tessa Munt Liberal Democrat
Susan Murray Liberal Democrat
Andrew Murrison Conservative
Jesse Norman Conservative
Neil O'Brien Conservative
Ben Obese-Jecty Conservative
Sarah Olney Liberal Democrat
Priti Patel Conservative
Rebecca Paul Conservative
Manuela Perteghella Liberal Democrat
Chris Philp Conservative
Al Pinkerton Liberal Democrat
Mark Pritchard Conservative
Shivani Raja Conservative (proxy vote cast by Gagan Mohindra)
Jack Rankin Conservative
David Reed Conservative
Joshua Reynolds Liberal Democrat
Joe Robertson Conservative
Ian Roome Liberal Democrat
Roz Savage Liberal Democrat
Jim Shannon DUP
Neil Shastri-Hurst Conservative
Alec Shelbrooke Conservative
David Simmonds Conservative
Vikki Slade Liberal Democrat
Lisa Smart Liberal Democrat
Greg Smith Conservative
Julian Smith Conservative
Rebecca Smith Conservative
Ian Sollom Liberal Democrat
Ben Spencer Conservative
Patrick Spencer Conservative
Blake Stephenson Conservative
Jamie Stone Liberal Democrat
Graham Stuart Conservative
Robin Swann UUP
Desmond Swayne Conservative
Bradley Thomas Conservative
Richard Tice Reform UK
Nick Timothy Conservative
Thomas Tugendhat Conservative
Matt Vickers Conservative
Martin Vickers Conservative
Caroline Voaden Liberal Democrat
John Whittingdale Conservative
James Wild Conservative
Max Wilkinson Liberal Democrat
Gavin Williamson Conservative
Munira Wilson Liberal Democrat
Sammy Wilson DUP
Mike Wood Conservative
Jeremy Wright Conservative

Tellers

Katie Lam Conservative
Gregory Stafford Conservative

No: A-Z by last name

Jack Abbott Labour/Co-operative
Diane Abbott Labour (proxy vote cast by Bell Ribeiro-Addy)
Zubir Ahmed Labour
Luke Akehurst Labour
Sadik Al-Hassan Labour
Bayo Alaba Labour
Douglas Alexander Labour/Co-operative
Heidi Alexander Labour
Rushanara Ali Labour
Tahir Ali Labour
Rosena Allin-Khan Labour
Callum Anderson Labour
Fleur Anderson Labour
Scott Arthur Labour
James Asser Labour
Jas Athwal Labour
Catherine Atkinson Labour
Calvin Bailey Labour
Olivia Bailey Labour
David Baines Labour
Richard Baker Labour
Alex Baker Labour
Alex Ballinger Labour
Antonia Bance Labour
Paula Barker Labour
Lee Barron Labour
Alex Barros-Curtis Labour
Johanna Baxter Labour
Danny Beales Labour
Lorraine Beavers Labour
Apsana Begum Independent (proxy vote cast by Zarah Sultana)
Torsten Bell Labour
Hilary Benn Labour
Siân Berry Green
Clive Betts Labour
Polly Billington Labour
Matt Bishop Labour
Rachel Blake Labour/Co-operative
Olivia Blake Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Elsie Blundell Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Kevin Bonavia Labour
Jade Botterill Labour
Sureena Brackenridge Labour
Jonathan Brash Labour
Phil Brickell Labour
Chris Bryant Labour
Julia Buckley Labour
Richard Burgon Labour
David Burton-Sampson Labour
Dawn Butler Labour
Nesil Caliskan Labour
Irene Campbell Labour
Alan Campbell Labour
Juliet Campbell Labour
Markus Campbell-Savours Labour
Dan Carden Labour
Sam Carling Labour
Alistair Carns Labour
Sarah Champion Labour
Bambos Charalambous Labour
Luke Charters Labour
Ellie Chowns Green
Jacob Collier Labour
Tom Collins Labour
Liam Conlon Labour
Sarah Coombes Labour
Andrew Cooper Labour
Deirdre Costigan Labour
Pam Cox Labour
Neil Coyle Labour
Jennifer Craft Labour
Mary Creagh Labour
Stella Creasy Labour/Co-operative
Torcuil Crichton Labour
Chris Curtis Labour
Janet Daby Labour
Nicholas Dakin Labour
Ashley Dalton Labour
Paul Davies Labour
Shaun Davies Labour
Ann Davies Plaid Cymru
Jonathan Davies Labour
Marsha de Cordova Labour
Josh Dean Labour
Kate Dearden Labour/Co-operative
Carla Denyer Green
Tan Dhesi Labour
Jim Dickson Labour
Anna Dixon Labour
Samantha Dixon Labour
Anneliese Dodds Labour/Co-operative
Helena Dollimore Labour/Co-operative
Dave Doogan Scottish National Party
Stephen Doughty Labour/Co-operative
Peter Dowd Labour
Graeme Downie Labour
Neil Duncan-Jordan Labour
Angela Eagle Labour
Maria Eagle Labour
Lauren Edwards Labour
Sarah Edwards Labour
Clive Efford Labour
Damien Egan Labour
Maya Ellis Labour
Chris Elmore Labour
Kirith Entwistle Labour
Florence Eshalomi Labour/Co-operative
Bill Esterson Labour
Chris Evans Labour/Co-operative
Miatta Fahnbulleh Labour/Co-operative
Josh Fenton-Glynn Labour
Patricia Ferguson Labour
Mark Ferguson Labour
Natalie Fleet Labour
Stephen Flynn Scottish National Party
Emma Foody Labour/Co-operative
Paul Foster Labour
Vicky Foxcroft Labour
Mary Foy Labour
Daniel Francis Labour
James Frith Labour
Gill Furniss Labour
Barry Gardiner Labour
Allison Gardner Labour
Anna Gelderd Labour
Alan Gemmell Labour
Gill German Labour
Stephen Gethins Scottish National Party
Tracy Gilbert Labour
Preet Kaur Gill Labour/Co-operative
Mary Glindon Labour
Ben Goldsborough Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Jodie Gosling Labour
Georgia Gould Labour
John Grady Labour
Lilian Greenwood Labour
Andrew Gwynne Independent (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Sarah Hall Labour/Co-operative
Paulette Hamilton Labour
Fabian Hamilton Labour
Emma Hardy Labour
Lloyd Hatton Labour
Helen Hayes Labour
Claire Hazelgrove Labour
John Healey Labour
Jonathan Hinder Labour
Sharon Hodgson Labour
Rachel Hopkins Labour
Claire Hughes Labour
Alison Hume Labour
Rupa Huq Labour
Patrick Hurley Labour
Imran Hussain Labour
Natasha Irons Labour
Sally Jameson Labour/Co-operative
Dan Jarvis Labour
Terry Jermy Labour
Kim Johnson Labour
Diana R. Johnson Labour
Sarah Jones Labour
Louise Jones Labour
Darren Jones Labour
Lillian Jones Labour
Gerald Jones Labour
Gurinder Josan Labour
Sojan Joseph Labour
Warinder Juss Labour
Chris Kane Labour
Satvir Kaur Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Afzal Khan Labour
Naushabah Khan Labour
Jayne Kirkham Labour/Co-operative
Gen Kitchen Labour
Sonia Kumar Labour
Uma Kumaran Labour
Peter Kyle Labour
Ben Lake Plaid Cymru
Peter Lamb Labour
Ian Lavery Labour
Noah Law Labour
Chris Law Scottish National Party
Kim Leadbeater Labour
Graham Leadbitter Scottish National Party
Brian Leishman Labour
Emma Lewell-Buck Labour
Andrew Lewin Labour
Simon Lightwood Labour/Co-operative
Seamus Logan Scottish National Party
Rebecca Long-Bailey Labour
Josh MacAlister Labour
Alice Macdonald Labour/Co-operative
Andy MacNae Labour
Justin Madders Labour
Seema Malhotra Labour/Co-operative
Amanda Martin Labour
Rachael Maskell Labour/Co-operative
Alex Mayer Labour
Douglas McAllister Labour
Kerry McCarthy Labour
Martin McCluskey Labour
Andy McDonald Labour
Chris McDonald Labour
John Martin McDonnell Independent
Blair McDougall Labour
Lola McEvoy Labour
Pat McFadden Labour
Alex McIntyre Labour
Gordon McKee Labour
Kevin McKenna Labour
Catherine McKinnell Labour
Jim McMahon Labour/Co-operative
Frank McNally Labour
Kirsty McNeill Labour/Co-operative
Llinos Medi Plaid Cymru
Anneliese Midgley Labour
Ed Miliband Labour
Julie Minns Labour
Navendu Mishra Labour
Abtisam Mohamed Labour
Perran Moon Labour
Stephen Morgan Labour
Grahame Morris Labour
Joe Morris Labour
Margaret Mullane Labour
Luke Murphy Labour
James Murray Labour/Co-operative
Chris Murray Labour
Ian Murray Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Luke Myer Labour
James Naish Labour
Pamela Nash Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Josh Newbury Labour
Samantha Niblett Labour
Charlotte Nichols Labour
Brendan O'Hara Scottish National Party
Melanie Onn Labour
Simon Opher Labour
Abena Oppong-Asare Labour
Kate Osborne Labour (proxy vote cast by Kim Johnson)
Tristan Osborne Labour
Sarah Owen Labour
Darren Paffey Labour
Andrew Pakes Labour/Co-operative
Matthew Patrick Labour
Michael Payne Labour
Jonathan Pearce Labour
Matthew Pennycook Labour
Jess Phillips Labour
David Pinto-Duschinsky Labour
Lee Pitcher Labour
Jo Platt Labour/Co-operative
Luke Pollard Labour/Co-operative
Joe Powell Labour
Lucy Powell Labour/Co-operative
Gregor Poynton Labour
Peter Prinsley Labour
Richard Quigley Labour
Yasmin Qureshi Labour
Adrian Ramsay Green
Andrew Ranger Labour
Mike Reader Labour
Steve Reed Labour/Co-operative
Joani Reid Labour
Emma Reynolds Labour
Jonathan Reynolds Labour/Co-operative
Martin Rhodes Labour
Bell Ribeiro-Addy Labour
Jake Richards Labour
Marie Rimmer Labour
Dave Robertson Labour
Tim Roca Labour
Matt Rodda Labour
Sam Rushworth Labour
Sarah Russell Labour
Tom Rutland Labour
Oliver Ryan Independent
Sarah Sackman Labour
Jeevun Sandher Labour
Liz Saville-Roberts Plaid Cymru
Michelle Scrogham Labour
Mark Sewards Labour
Naseem Shah Labour
Baggy Shanker Labour/Co-operative
Michael Shanks Labour
Tulip Siddiq Labour
Josh Simons Labour
Andrew Slaughter Labour
John Slinger Labour
Jeff Smith Labour
Cat Smith Labour
Sarah Smith Labour
Nick Smith Labour
Gareth Snell Labour/Co-operative
Alex Sobel Labour/Co-operative
Euan Stainbank Labour
Jo Stevens Labour
Kenneth Stevenson Labour
Will Stone Labour
Alistair Strathern Labour
Alan Strickland Labour
Graham Stringer Labour
Kirsteen Sullivan Labour/Co-operative
Zarah Sultana Independent
Mark Tami Labour
Mike Tapp Labour
David Taylor Labour
Alison Taylor Labour
Rachel Taylor Labour
Emily Thornberry Labour
Marie Tidball Labour
Stephen Timms Labour
Jessica Toale Labour
Henry Tufnell Labour
Anna Turley Labour/Co-operative
Matt Turmaine Labour
Laurence Turner Labour
Karl Turner Labour
Derek Twigg Labour
Liz Twist Labour
Harpreet Uppal Labour
Tony Vaughan Labour
Christopher Vince Labour/Co-operative
Christian Wakeford Labour
Imogen Walker Labour
Chris Ward Labour
Melanie Ward Labour
Paul Waugh Labour/Co-operative
Chris Webb Labour
Michelle Welsh Labour
Catherine West Labour
Matt Western Labour
Andrew Western Labour
Michael Wheeler Labour
John Whitby Labour
Jo White Labour
Katie White Labour
Nadia Whittome Labour
David Williams Labour
Steve Witherden Labour
Sean Woodcock Labour
Rosie Wrighting Labour
Yuan Yang Labour
Mohammad Yasin Labour
Steve Yemm Labour
Daniel Zeichner Labour

Tellers

Keir Mather Labour
Taiwo Owatemi Labour

Link to this vote In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 3 March 2025, c104)

The House divided: Ayes 167, Noes 347.

Question accordingly negatived.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 3 March 2025, c104)

TheyWorkForYou

Clause 47 - Removal of exemption for private school fees

Votes in this debate

Division number 111 Finance Bill — Clause 47 - Removal of exemption for private school fees

Aye: 165 MPs

No: 345 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Tellers

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

TheyWorkForYou