Clause 4 - Decisions based on particular individual circumstances: 15 Apr 2024: House of Commons debates

Division number 119

Motion made, and Question put,

That this House disagrees with the Lords in their Amendment 6B. —(Michael Tomlinson.)

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 15 April 2024, c116)

Aye: 315 MPs

No: 250 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Bim Afolami Conservative
Adam Afriyie Conservative
Nickie Aiken Conservative
Peter Aldous Conservative
Stuart Anderson Conservative (proxy vote cast by Marcus Jones)
Stuart Andrew Conservative
Caroline Ansell Conservative
Edward Argar Conservative
Sarah Atherton Conservative
Victoria Atkins Conservative
Gareth Bacon Conservative
Richard Bacon Conservative
Kemi Badenoch Conservative
Shaun Bailey Conservative
Siobhan Baillie Conservative
Duncan Baker Conservative
Steven Baker Conservative
Harriett Baldwin Conservative
Steve Barclay Conservative
John Baron Conservative
Simon Baynes Conservative
Aaron Bell Conservative
Paul Beresford Conservative
Jake Berry Conservative
Saqib Bhatti Conservative
Bob Blackman Conservative
Peter Bottomley Conservative
Andrew Bowie Conservative
Karen Bradley Conservative
Ben Bradley Conservative
Graham Brady Conservative
Jack Brereton Conservative
Steve Brine Conservative
Paul Bristow Conservative
Sara Britcliffe Conservative
Anthony Browne Conservative
Fiona Bruce Conservative
Felicity Buchan Conservative
Robert Buckland Conservative
Alex Burghart Conservative
Conor Burns Conservative
Rob Butler Conservative
Alun Cairns Conservative
Lisa Cameron Conservative
Gregory Campbell DUP
Andy Carter Conservative
James Cartlidge Conservative
Bill Cash Conservative
Miriam Cates Conservative
Maria Caulfield Conservative
Alex Chalk Conservative
Rehman Chishti Conservative
Christopher Chope Conservative
Jo Churchill Conservative
Theo Clarke Conservative
Simon Clarke Conservative
Brendan Clarke-Smith Conservative
Chris Clarkson Conservative
James Cleverly Conservative
Therese Coffey Conservative
Elliot Colburn Conservative
Damian Collins Conservative
Alberto Costa Conservative
Robert Courts Conservative
Claire Coutinho Conservative
Geoffrey Cox Conservative
Stephen Crabb Conservative
Virginia Crosbie Conservative
Tracey Crouch Conservative
James Daly Conservative
Gareth Davies Conservative
Philip Davies Conservative
Mims Davies Conservative
James Davies Conservative
David Davies Conservative
David Davis Conservative
Dehenna Davison Conservative
Caroline Dinenage Conservative
Sarah Dines Conservative
Jonathan Djanogly Conservative
Leo Docherty Conservative
Michelle Donelan Conservative
Steve Double Conservative
Oliver Dowden Conservative
Jackie Doyle-Price Conservative
Flick Drummond Conservative
James Duddridge Conservative (proxy vote cast by Mark Francois)
Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
Philip Dunne Conservative
Mark Eastwood Conservative
Ruth Edwards Conservative
Michael Ellis Conservative
Tobias Ellwood Conservative
George Eustice Conservative
Luke Evans Conservative
David Evennett Conservative
Ben Everitt Conservative
Michael Fabricant Conservative
Laura Farris Conservative
Simon Fell Conservative
Anna Firth Conservative
Katherine Fletcher Conservative
Nicholas Fletcher Conservative
Mark Fletcher Conservative
Vicky Ford Conservative
Kevin Foster Conservative
Liam Fox Conservative
Mark Francois Conservative
Lucy Frazer Conservative
George Freeman Conservative
Mike Freer Conservative
Louie French Conservative
Richard Fuller Conservative
Marcus Fysh Conservative
Mark Garnier Conservative
Nusrat Ghani Conservative
Nick Gibb Conservative
Peter Gibson Conservative
Jo Gideon Conservative
John Glen Conservative
Robert Goodwill Conservative
Michael Gove Conservative
Richard Graham Conservative
Helen Grant Conservative
James Gray Conservative
Chris Grayling Conservative
Chris Green Conservative
Damian Green Conservative
Andrew Griffith Conservative
James Grundy Conservative
Jonathan Gullis Conservative
Luke Hall Conservative
Stephen Hammond Conservative
Greg Hands Conservative
Mark Harper Conservative
Rebecca Harris Conservative
Trudy Harrison Conservative
Sally-Ann Hart Conservative
Simon Hart Conservative
John Hayes Conservative
Oliver Heald Conservative
James Heappey Conservative
Chris Heaton-Harris Conservative
Gordon Henderson Conservative
Darren Henry Conservative
Antony Higginbotham Conservative
Damian Hinds Conservative
Simon Hoare Conservative
Kevin Hollinrake Conservative
Philip Hollobone Conservative
Paul Holmes Conservative
John Howell Conservative (proxy vote cast by Marcus Jones)
Paul Howell Conservative
Nigel Huddleston Conservative
Neil Hudson Conservative
Eddie Hughes Conservative
Jane Hunt Conservative
Jeremy Hunt Conservative
Tom Hunt Conservative
Alister Jack Conservative
Sajid Javid Conservative
Ranil Jayawardena Conservative
Mark Jenkinson Conservative
Dr Caroline Johnson Conservative
Gareth Johnson Conservative
David Johnston Conservative
Marcus Jones Conservative
Andrew Jones Conservative
Fay Jones Conservative
David Jones Conservative
Simon Jupp Conservative
Daniel Kawczynski Conservative
Gillian Keegan Conservative
Greg Knight Conservative
Kate Kniveton Conservative
Danny Kruger Conservative
John Lamont Conservative
Robert Largan Conservative
Pauline Latham Conservative
Andrea Leadsom Conservative
Edward Leigh Conservative
Ian Levy Conservative
Andrew Lewer Conservative
Brandon Lewis Conservative
Julian Lewis Conservative
Chris Loder Conservative
Mark Logan Conservative
Marco Longhi Conservative
Julia Lopez Conservative
Jonathan Lord Conservative
Tim Loughton Conservative
Craig Mackinlay Conservative (proxy vote cast by John Redwood)
Cherilyn Mackrory Conservative
Rachel Maclean Conservative
Alan Mak Conservative
Kit Malthouse Conservative
Anthony Mangnall Conservative
Scott Mann Conservative
Julie Marson Conservative
Jerome Mayhew Conservative
Paul Maynard Conservative
Jason McCartney Conservative
Karl McCartney Conservative
Stephen McPartland Conservative
Esther McVey Conservative
Mark Menzies Conservative
Johnny Mercer Conservative
Huw Merriman Conservative
Stephen Metcalfe Conservative
Robin Millar Conservative
Maria Miller Conservative
Amanda Milling Conservative
Nigel Mills Conservative
Andrew Mitchell Conservative
Gagan Mohindra Conservative
Damien Moore Conservative
Robbie Moore Conservative
Penny Mordaunt Conservative
James Morris Conservative
David Morris Conservative
Anne Marie Morris Conservative
Joy Morrissey Conservative
Jill Mortimer Conservative
Kieran Mullan Conservative
Holly Mumby-Croft Conservative
David Mundell Conservative
Sheryll Murray Conservative
Andrew Murrison Conservative
Lia Nici Conservative
Neil O'Brien Conservative
Guy Opperman Conservative
Priti Patel Conservative
Mark Pawsey Conservative
John Penrose Conservative
Chris Philp Conservative
Rebecca Pow Conservative
Victoria Prentis Conservative
Mark Pritchard Conservative
Tom Pursglove Conservative
Jeremy Quin Conservative
Will Quince Conservative
Tom Randall Conservative
John Redwood Conservative
Jacob Rees-Mogg Conservative
Nicola Richards Conservative
Angela Richardson Conservative
Laurence Robertson Conservative
Gavin Robinson DUP
Mary Robinson Conservative
Andrew Rosindell Conservative
Douglas Ross Conservative
Lee Rowley Conservative
Dean Russell Conservative
David Rutley Conservative
Gary Sambrook Conservative
Selaine Saxby Conservative
Paul Scully Conservative
Bob Seely Conservative
Andrew Selous Conservative
Jim Shannon DUP
Grant Shapps Conservative
Alec Shelbrooke Conservative
David Simmonds Conservative
Royston Smith Conservative
Greg Smith Conservative
Julian Smith Conservative
Chloe Smith Conservative
Henry Smith Conservative
Mark Spencer Conservative
Ben Spencer Conservative
Alexander Stafford Conservative
Andrew Stephenson Conservative
John Stevenson Conservative
Jane Stevenson Conservative
Iain Stewart Conservative
Gary Streeter Conservative
Mel Stride Conservative
Graham Stuart Conservative
Julian Sturdy Conservative
James Sunderland Conservative
Desmond Swayne Conservative
Robert Syms Conservative
Derek Thomas Conservative
Maggie Throup Conservative
Edward Timpson Conservative
Kelly Tolhurst Conservative
Justin Tomlinson Conservative
Michael Tomlinson Conservative
Craig Tracey Conservative
Anne-Marie Trevelyan Conservative
Laura Trott Conservative
Elizabeth Truss Conservative
Steve Tuckwell Conservative
Thomas Tugendhat Conservative
Shailesh Vara Conservative
Martin Vickers Conservative
Matt Vickers Conservative
Theresa Villiers Conservative
Charles Walker Conservative
Robin Walker Conservative
Ben Wallace Conservative
Jamie Wallis Conservative
Matt Warman Conservative
Giles Watling Conservative
Suzanne Webb Conservative
Helen Whately Conservative
Heather Wheeler Conservative
Craig Whittaker Conservative
John Whittingdale Conservative
Bill Wiggin Conservative
James Wild Conservative
Craig Williams Conservative
Sammy Wilson DUP
Jeremy Wright Conservative
Jacob Young Conservative

Tellers

Amanda Solloway Conservative
Mike Wood Conservative

No: A-Z by last name

Diane Abbott Independent (proxy vote cast by Bell Ribeiro-Addy)
Debbie Abrahams Labour
Rushanara Ali Labour
Tahir Ali Labour
Rosena Allin-Khan Labour
Mike Amesbury Labour
Fleur Anderson Labour
Jon Ashworth Labour
Hannah Bardell Scottish National Party
Paula Barker Labour
Margaret Beckett Labour
Apsana Begum Labour
Hilary Benn Labour
Clive Betts Labour
Mhairi Black Scottish National Party
Ian Blackford Scottish National Party
Kirsty Blackman Scottish National Party
Olivia Blake Labour
Paul Blomfield Labour
Steven Bonnar Scottish National Party
Ben Bradshaw Labour
Deidre Brock Scottish National Party
Alan Brown Scottish National Party
Nick Brown Independent
Lyn Brown Labour
Chris Bryant Labour
Karen Buck Labour
Richard Burgon Labour
Dawn Butler Labour
Ian Byrne Labour
Ruth Cadbury Labour
Amy Callaghan Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Alan Campbell Labour
Dan Carden Labour
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
Wendy Chamberlain Liberal Democrat
Sarah Champion Labour
Douglas Chapman Scottish National Party
Bambos Charalambous Independent
Joanna Cherry Scottish National Party
Feryal Clark Labour
Yvette Cooper Labour
Daisy Cooper Liberal Democrat
Jeremy Corbyn Independent
Ronnie Cowan Scottish National Party
Neil Coyle Labour
Angela Crawley Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Stella Creasy Labour/Co-operative
Jon Cruddas Labour
John Cryer Labour
Judith Cummins Labour
Alex Cunningham Labour
Janet Daby Labour
Ashley Dalton Labour
Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
Wayne David Labour
Alex Davies-Jones Labour
Martyn Day Scottish National Party
Marsha de Cordova Labour
Thangam Debbonaire Labour
Tan Dhesi Labour
Martin Docherty Scottish National Party
Anneliese Dodds Labour/Co-operative
Dave Doogan Scottish National Party
Allan Dorans Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Stephen Doughty Labour/Co-operative
Rosie Duffield Labour
Sarah Dyke Liberal Democrat
Maria Eagle Labour
Angela Eagle Labour
Colum Eastwood Social Democratic and Labour Party
Jonathan Edwards Independent
Sarah Edwards Labour
Clive Efford Labour
Damien Egan Labour
Julie Elliott Labour
Chris Elmore Labour
Florence Eshalomi Labour/Co-operative
Bill Esterson Labour
Chris Evans Labour/Co-operative
Tim Farron Liberal Democrat
Stephen Farry Alliance
Marion Fellows Scottish National Party
Colleen Fletcher Labour
Richard Foord Liberal Democrat
Yvonne Fovargue Labour
Vicky Foxcroft Labour
Gill Furniss Labour
George Galloway Workers Party
Barry Gardiner Labour
Patricia Gibson Scottish National Party
Preet Kaur Gill Labour/Co-operative
Mary Glindon Labour
Patrick Grady Scottish National Party
Peter Grant Scottish National Party
Sarah Green Liberal Democrat
Lilian Greenwood Labour
Margaret Greenwood Labour
Nia Griffith Labour
Andrew Gwynne Labour
Louise Haigh Labour
Paulette Hamilton Labour
Fabian Hamilton Labour
Claire Hanna Social Democratic and Labour Party
Neale Hanvey Alba
Emma Hardy Labour
Harriet Harman Labour
Carolyn Harris Labour
Helen Hayes Labour
John Healey Labour
Drew Hendry Scottish National Party
Meg Hillier Labour/Co-operative
Wera Hobhouse Liberal Democrat
Margaret Hodge Labour
Sharon Hodgson Labour
Rachel Hopkins Labour
Stewart Hosie Scottish National Party
George Howarth Labour
Rupa Huq Labour
Imran Hussain Labour
Christine Jardine Liberal Democrat
Dan Jarvis Labour
Kim Johnson Labour
Diana R. Johnson Labour
Gerald Jones Labour
Darren Jones Labour
Ruth Jones Labour
Kevan Jones Labour
Mike Kane Labour
Barbara Keeley Labour
Afzal Khan Labour
Stephen Kinnock Labour
Gen Kitchen Labour
Peter Kyle Labour
Ben Lake Plaid Cymru
David Lammy Labour
Ian Lavery Labour
Chris Law Scottish National Party
Kim Leadbeater Labour
Emma Lewell-Buck Labour
Simon Lightwood Labour
David Linden Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Caroline Lucas Green
Holly Lynch Labour
Justin Madders Labour
Shabana Mahmood Labour
Khalid Mahmood Labour
Seema Malhotra Labour/Co-operative
Rachael Maskell Labour/Co-operative
Keir Mather Labour
Steve McCabe Labour
Kerry McCarthy Labour
Stuart McDonald Scottish National Party
Stewart McDonald Scottish National Party
Andy McDonald Labour
John Martin McDonnell Labour
Pat McFadden Labour
Conor McGinn Independent
Alison McGovern Labour
Catherine McKinnell Labour
Anne McLaughlin Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Jim McMahon Labour/Co-operative
Anna McMorrin Labour
John McNally Scottish National Party
Ian Mearns Labour
Ed Miliband Labour
Navendu Mishra Labour
Carol Monaghan Scottish National Party
Layla Moran Liberal Democrat
Jessica Morden Labour
Stephen Morgan Labour
Helen Morgan Liberal Democrat
Grahame Morris Labour
James Murray Labour/Co-operative
Ian Murray Labour
Lisa Nandy Labour
Gavin Newlands Scottish National Party
Charlotte Nichols Labour
John Nicolson Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Alex Norris Labour/Co-operative
Brendan O'Hara Scottish National Party
Sarah Olney Liberal Democrat
Chi Onwurah Labour
Kate Osborne Labour
Kirsten Oswald Scottish National Party
Taiwo Owatemi Labour (proxy vote cast by Chris Elmore)
Stephanie Peacock Labour
Matthew Pennycook Labour
Toby Perkins Labour
Jess Phillips Labour
Bridget Phillipson Labour
Luke Pollard Labour/Co-operative
Lucy Powell Labour/Co-operative
Anum Qaisar Scottish National Party
Yasmin Qureshi Labour
Angela Rayner Labour
Christina Rees Independent
Rachel Reeves Labour
Ellie Reeves Labour
Jonathan Reynolds Labour/Co-operative
Bell Ribeiro-Addy Labour
Marie Rimmer Labour
Matt Rodda Labour
Lloyd Russell-Moyle Labour/Co-operative
Liz Saville-Roberts Plaid Cymru
Naseem Shah Labour
Michael Shanks Labour
Virendra Sharma Labour
Barry Sheerman Labour/Co-operative
Tulip Siddiq Labour
Andrew Slaughter Labour
Alyn Smith Scottish National Party
Jeff Smith Labour
Cat Smith Labour
Nick Smith Labour
Karin Smyth Labour (proxy vote cast by Gerald Jones)
Alex Sobel Labour/Co-operative
John Spellar Labour
Keir Starmer Labour
Chris Stephens Scottish National Party
Jo Stevens Labour
Jamie Stone Liberal Democrat
Wes Streeting Labour
Graham Stringer Labour
Zarah Sultana Labour
Mark Tami Labour
Sam Tarry Labour
Alison Thewliss Scottish National Party
Gareth Thomas Labour/Co-operative
Nick Thomas-Symonds Labour
Owen Thompson Scottish National Party
Emily Thornberry Labour
Stephen Timms Labour
Jon Trickett Labour (proxy vote cast by Ian Lavery)
Karl Turner Labour
Derek Twigg Labour
Liz Twist Labour
Valerie Vaz Labour
Christian Wakeford Labour
Claudia Webbe Independent
Catherine West Labour
Matt Western Labour
Alan Whitehead Labour
Philippa Whitford Scottish National Party (proxy vote cast by Owen Thompson)
Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
Munira Wilson Liberal Democrat
Beth Winter Labour
Pete Wishart Scottish National Party
Mohammad Yasin Labour
Daniel Zeichner Labour

Tellers

Tonia Antoniazzi Labour
Andrew Western Labour

Link to this vote In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 15 April 2024, c117)

The House divided: Ayes 319, Noes 249.

Question accordingly agreed to.

Resolved,

That this House disagrees with the Lords in their Amendment 6B.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
(Citation: HC Deb, 15 April 2024, c117)

TheyWorkForYou

Clause 4 - Decisions based on particular individual circumstances

Votes in this debate

Division number 119 That this House disagrees with the Lords in their Amendment 6B

Aye: 315 MPs

No: 250 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Tellers

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

TheyWorkForYou