Part of the debate – in the House of Commons at 5:13 pm on 8th March 2017.
Alert me about debates like this
Order. I do not think that the shadow Chancellor is aware of how loudly he is speaking. It is quite difficult to hear Mr Carmichael.
Making it easy to keep an eye on the UK’s parliaments. Discover who represents you, how they’ve voted and what they’ve said in debates – simply and clearly.
Get insights on TheyWorkForYou and other mySociety sites, in our popular newsletter
Your donations keep this site and others like it running
mySociety Limited is a project of UK Citizens Online Democracy, a registered charity in England and Wales. For full details visit mysociety.org.