Legal Advice (Declaration of War)

Oral Answers to Questions — Attorney-General – in the House of Commons at 2:30 pm on 5th July 2011.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Graham Allen Graham Allen Chair, Political and Constitutional Reform Committee, Chair, Political and Constitutional Reform Committee 2:30 pm, 5th July 2011

What steps he is taking to ensure transparency in the arrangements for the provision of legal advice to the Cabinet on a declaration of war.

Photo of Edward Garnier Edward Garnier The Solicitor-General

The hon. Gentleman’s Political and Constitutional Reform Committee reported in May on Parliament’s role in conflict decisions, and the Government will respond to his report shortly. The Foreign Secretary told the House on 21 March in the Libya debate that the Cabinet had the Attorney-General’s advice before it when the decision was made to take action in Libya. A Government note on the legal basis was placed in the Library that day, and was available to right hon. and hon. Members for that debate.

Photo of Graham Allen Graham Allen Chair, Political and Constitutional Reform Committee, Chair, Political and Constitutional Reform Committee

The Solicitor-General knows better than most of us that there is a separation of powers, at least theoretically, in our constitution, and that the problems that we had over legal advice in relation to the Iraq war centred around the legal advice given to the Government by their own Attorney-General. Will he also take into account that Parliament has no right whatever to consult and get its own legal advice? Will he discuss with the House authorities putting that right, so that on future occasions when there is a conflict, Members can get their own advice rather than relying on trying to wheedle the Attorney-General’s advice out of Government?

Photo of Edward Garnier Edward Garnier The Solicitor-General

It is not for me to stop Members of Parliament getting whatever advice they think it appropriate to have, but the decision that has to be considered and accounted for to Parliament is that of the Prime Minister and the Government. That can be debated here, irrespective of one’s access to legal advice.

P

Crime Report August 2011 Allegations We assert that successive Prime Ministers and Attorney Generals, members of the successive Cabinets, Members of both Houses of Parliament,...

Submitted by Paul McEvoy Continue reading