Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Bill: 16 Nov 2005: House of Commons debates

Division number 97
Division number 98

Amendment proposed: No. 47, in page 1, line 3, leave out clause 1.—[Dr. Evan Harris.]

Question put, That the amendment be made:—

The House divided: Ayes 228, Noes 270.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 16 November 2005, c1021)

Aye: 228 MPs

No: 270 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Adam Afriyie Conservative
Peter Ainsworth Conservative
Danny Alexander Liberal Democrat
Sir David Amess Conservative
Michael Ancram Conservative
Peter Atkinson Conservative
Richard Bacon Conservative
Tony Baldry Conservative
Gregory Barker Conservative
John Baron Conservative
Alan Beith Liberal Democrat
Henry Bellingham Conservative
Richard Benyon Conservative
Paul Beresford Conservative
Brian Binley Conservative
Peter Bone Conservative
Tim Boswell Conservative
Graham Brady Conservative
Tom Brake Liberal Democrat
Julian Brazier Conservative
Colin Breed Liberal Democrat
James Brokenshire Conservative
Annette Brooke Liberal Democrat
Jeremy Browne Liberal Democrat
Angela Browning Conservative
Simon Burns Conservative
David Burrowes Conservative
Paul Burstow Liberal Democrat
Lorely Burt Liberal Democrat
Alistair Burt Conservative
John Butterfill Conservative
Vincent Cable Liberal Democrat
Gregory Campbell DUP
Menzies Campbell Liberal Democrat
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
Douglas Carswell Conservative
Christopher Chope Conservative
James Clappison Conservative
Greg Clark Conservative
Nick Clegg Liberal Democrat
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative
Derek Conway Conservative
Patrick Cormack Conservative
Geoffrey Cox Conservative
Stephen Crabb Conservative
Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
David Davies Conservative
Philip Davies Conservative
Nigel Dodds DUP
Jeffrey M. Donaldson DUP
Stephen Dorrell Conservative
Nadine Dorries Conservative
James Duddridge Conservative
Alan Duncan Conservative
Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
Tobias Ellwood Conservative
Nigel Evans Conservative
David Evennett Conservative
Michael Fabricant Conservative
Michael Fallon Conservative
Tim Farron Liberal Democrat
Lynne Featherstone Liberal Democrat
Mark Field Conservative
Eric Forth Conservative
Don Foster Liberal Democrat
Liam Fox Conservative
Mark Francois Conservative
Roger Gale Conservative
David Gauke Conservative
Andrew George Liberal Democrat
Nick Gibb Conservative
Sandra Gidley Liberal Democrat
Dame Cheryl Gillan Conservative
Julia Goldsworthy Liberal Democrat
Paul Goodman Conservative
Robert Goodwill Conservative
Michael Gove Conservative
James Gray Conservative
Chris Grayling Conservative
Damian Green Conservative
John Greenway Conservative
Dominic Grieve Conservative
William Hague Conservative
Stephen Hammond Conservative
Philip Hammond Conservative
Greg Hands Conservative
Mark Harper Conservative
Evan Harris Liberal Democrat
Nick Harvey Liberal Democrat
John Hayes Conservative
Oliver Heald Conservative
David Heath Liberal Democrat
David Heathcoat-Amory Conservative
John Hemming Liberal Democrat
Charles Hendry Conservative
Nick Herbert Conservative
Mark Hoban Conservative
Douglas Hogg Conservative
Philip Hollobone Conservative
Adam Holloway Conservative
Paul Holmes Liberal Democrat
John Horam Conservative
Martin Horwood Liberal Democrat
David Howarth Liberal Democrat
Simon Hughes Liberal Democrat
Christopher Huhne Liberal Democrat
Jeremy Hunt Conservative
Mark Hunter Liberal Democrat
Nick Hurd Conservative
Michael Jack Conservative
Stewart Jackson Conservative
Bernard Jenkin Conservative
Lynne Jones Labour
David Jones Conservative
Daniel Kawczynski Conservative
Charles Kennedy Liberal Democrat
Julie Kirkbride Conservative
Susan Kramer Liberal Democrat
Eleanor Laing Conservative
Jacqui Lait Conservative
Norman Lamb Liberal Democrat
Mark Lancaster Conservative
Andrew Lansley Conservative
John Leech Liberal Democrat
Edward Leigh Conservative
Julian Lewis Conservative
Ian Liddell-Grainger Conservative
David Lidington Conservative
Peter Lilley Conservative
Elfyn Llwyd Plaid Cymru
Tim Loughton Conservative
David Maclean Conservative
Angus MacNeil Scottish National Party
Anne Main Conservative
Humfrey Malins Conservative
John Maples Conservative
Michael Mates Conservative
Theresa May Conservative
William McCrea DUP
John Martin McDonnell Labour
Anne McIntosh Conservative
Patrick McLoughlin Conservative
Patrick Mercer Conservative
Maria Miller Conservative
Anne Milton Conservative
Andrew Mitchell Conservative
Michael Moore Liberal Democrat
Malcolm Moss Conservative
David Mundell Conservative
Andrew Murrison Conservative
Brooks Newmark Conservative
Stephen O'Brien Conservative
Mark Oaten Liberal Democrat
Lembit Öpik Liberal Democrat
Richard Ottaway Conservative
James Paice Conservative
Owen Paterson Conservative
Andrew Pelling Conservative
Mike Penning Conservative
Eric Pickles Conservative
Adam Price Plaid Cymru
Mark Prisk Conservative
Mark Pritchard Conservative
John Pugh Liberal Democrat
John Randall Conservative
John Redwood Conservative
Alan Reid Liberal Democrat
Malcolm Rifkind Conservative
Andrew Robathan Conservative
Angus Robertson Scottish National Party
Hugh Robertson Conservative
Laurence Robertson Conservative
Iris Robinson DUP
Peter Robinson DUP
Dan Rogerson Liberal Democrat
Paul Rowen Liberal Democrat
David Ruffley Conservative
Bob Russell Liberal Democrat
Adrian Sanders Liberal Democrat
Lee Scott Conservative
Andrew Selous Conservative
Grant Shapps Conservative
Richard Shepherd Conservative
Mark Simmonds Conservative
David Simpson DUP
Caroline Spelman Conservative
Michael Spicer Conservative
Bob Spink Conservative
Richard Spring Conservative
John Stanley Conservative
Anthony Steen Conservative
Graham Stuart Conservative
Desmond Swayne Conservative
Jo Swinson Liberal Democrat
Hugo Swire Conservative
Robert Syms Conservative
Peter Tapsell Conservative
Richard Taylor Independent
Sarah Teather Liberal Democrat
John Thurso Liberal Democrat
David Tredinnick Conservative
Andrew Turner Conservative
Andrew Tyrie Conservative
Ed Vaizey Conservative
Keith Vaz Labour
Peter Viggers Conservative
Theresa Villiers Conservative
Charles Walker Conservative
Ben Wallace Conservative
Nigel Waterson Conservative
Angela Watkinson Conservative
Steve Webb Liberal Democrat
Michael Weir Scottish National Party
John Whittingdale Conservative
Bill Wiggin Conservative
David Willetts Conservative
Stephen Williams Liberal Democrat
Mark Williams Liberal Democrat
Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
Roger Williams Liberal Democrat
Phil Willis Liberal Democrat
Sammy Wilson DUP
Rob Wilson Conservative
Ann Winterton Conservative
Pete Wishart Scottish National Party
Jeremy Wright Conservative
George Young Conservative
Richard Younger-Ross Liberal Democrat

Tellers

Crispin Blunt Conservative
Andrew Stunell Liberal Democrat

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

Vernon Coaker Labour
Frank Roy Labour

Link to this vote In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 16 November 2005, c1021)

Question accordingly negatived.

Amendment proposed: No. 6, in page 2, line 36, leave out Clause 4.—[Mrs. Gillan.]

Question put, That the amendment be made:—

The House divided: Ayes 225, Noes 272.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 16 November 2005, c1021)

Aye: 225 MPs

No: 272 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Adam Afriyie Conservative
Peter Ainsworth Conservative
Danny Alexander Liberal Democrat
Sir David Amess Conservative
Michael Ancram Conservative
Richard Bacon Conservative
Tony Baldry Conservative
Gregory Barker Conservative
John Baron Conservative
Alan Beith Liberal Democrat
Henry Bellingham Conservative
Richard Benyon Conservative
Paul Beresford Conservative
Brian Binley Conservative
Peter Bone Conservative
Tim Boswell Conservative
Tom Brake Liberal Democrat
Julian Brazier Conservative
Colin Breed Liberal Democrat
James Brokenshire Conservative
Annette Brooke Liberal Democrat
Jeremy Browne Liberal Democrat
Angela Browning Conservative
Simon Burns Conservative
David Burrowes Conservative
Paul Burstow Liberal Democrat
Lorely Burt Liberal Democrat
Alistair Burt Conservative
John Butterfill Conservative
Vincent Cable Liberal Democrat
Gregory Campbell DUP
Menzies Campbell Liberal Democrat
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
Douglas Carswell Conservative
Christopher Chope Conservative
James Clappison Conservative
Greg Clark Conservative
Nick Clegg Liberal Democrat
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative
Derek Conway Conservative
Patrick Cormack Conservative
Geoffrey Cox Conservative
Stephen Crabb Conservative
Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
David Davies Conservative
Philip Davies Conservative
Nigel Dodds DUP
Jeffrey M. Donaldson DUP
Stephen Dorrell Conservative
Nadine Dorries Conservative
James Duddridge Conservative
Alan Duncan Conservative
Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
Tobias Ellwood Conservative
Nigel Evans Conservative
David Evennett Conservative
Michael Fabricant Conservative
Michael Fallon Conservative
Tim Farron Liberal Democrat
Lynne Featherstone Liberal Democrat
Mark Field Conservative
Eric Forth Conservative
Don Foster Liberal Democrat
Liam Fox Conservative
Mark Francois Conservative
Roger Gale Conservative
David Gauke Conservative
Andrew George Liberal Democrat
Nick Gibb Conservative
Sandra Gidley Liberal Democrat
Dame Cheryl Gillan Conservative
Julia Goldsworthy Liberal Democrat
Paul Goodman Conservative
Robert Goodwill Conservative
Michael Gove Conservative
James Gray Conservative
Chris Grayling Conservative
Damian Green Conservative
John Greenway Conservative
Dominic Grieve Conservative
William Hague Conservative
Philip Hammond Conservative
Stephen Hammond Conservative
Greg Hands Conservative
Mark Harper Conservative
Evan Harris Liberal Democrat
Nick Harvey Liberal Democrat
John Hayes Conservative
Oliver Heald Conservative
David Heath Liberal Democrat
David Heathcoat-Amory Conservative
John Hemming Liberal Democrat
Charles Hendry Conservative
Nick Herbert Conservative
Mark Hoban Conservative
Douglas Hogg Conservative
Philip Hollobone Conservative
Adam Holloway Conservative
Paul Holmes Liberal Democrat
John Horam Conservative
Martin Horwood Liberal Democrat
David Howarth Liberal Democrat
Simon Hughes Liberal Democrat
Christopher Huhne Liberal Democrat
Jeremy Hunt Conservative
Mark Hunter Liberal Democrat
Nick Hurd Conservative
Michael Jack Conservative
Stewart Jackson Conservative
Bernard Jenkin Conservative
David Jones Conservative
Daniel Kawczynski Conservative
Charles Kennedy Liberal Democrat
Julie Kirkbride Conservative
Susan Kramer Liberal Democrat
Jacqui Lait Conservative
Norman Lamb Liberal Democrat
Mark Lancaster Conservative
Andrew Lansley Conservative
John Leech Liberal Democrat
Edward Leigh Conservative
Julian Lewis Conservative
Ian Liddell-Grainger Conservative
David Lidington Conservative
Peter Lilley Conservative
Elfyn Llwyd Plaid Cymru
Tim Loughton Conservative
Peter Luff Conservative
David Maclean Conservative
Angus MacNeil Scottish National Party
Anne Main Conservative
Humfrey Malins Conservative
John Maples Conservative
Michael Mates Conservative
Theresa May Conservative
William McCrea DUP
John Martin McDonnell Labour
Anne McIntosh Conservative
Patrick McLoughlin Conservative
Patrick Mercer Conservative
Maria Miller Conservative
Anne Milton Conservative
Andrew Mitchell Conservative
Michael Moore Liberal Democrat
Malcolm Moss Conservative
David Mundell Conservative
Andrew Murrison Conservative
Brooks Newmark Conservative
Stephen O'Brien Conservative
Mark Oaten Liberal Democrat
Lembit Öpik Liberal Democrat
Richard Ottaway Conservative
James Paice Conservative
Owen Paterson Conservative
Andrew Pelling Conservative
Mike Penning Conservative
Eric Pickles Conservative
Adam Price Plaid Cymru
Mark Prisk Conservative
Mark Pritchard Conservative
John Pugh Liberal Democrat
John Randall Conservative
John Redwood Conservative
Alan Reid Liberal Democrat
Malcolm Rifkind Conservative
Andrew Robathan Conservative
Hugh Robertson Conservative
Angus Robertson Scottish National Party
Laurence Robertson Conservative
Peter Robinson DUP
Iris Robinson DUP
Dan Rogerson Liberal Democrat
Paul Rowen Liberal Democrat
David Ruffley Conservative
Bob Russell Liberal Democrat
Adrian Sanders Liberal Democrat
Lee Scott Conservative
Andrew Selous Conservative
Grant Shapps Conservative
Richard Shepherd Conservative
David Simpson DUP
Robert Smith Liberal Democrat
Caroline Spelman Conservative
Michael Spicer Conservative
Bob Spink Conservative
Richard Spring Conservative
John Stanley Conservative
Anthony Steen Conservative
Graham Stuart Conservative
Andrew Stunell Liberal Democrat
Desmond Swayne Conservative
Jo Swinson Liberal Democrat
Hugo Swire Conservative
Robert Syms Conservative
Peter Tapsell Conservative
Richard Taylor Independent
Sarah Teather Liberal Democrat
John Thurso Liberal Democrat
David Tredinnick Conservative
Andrew Turner Conservative
Andrew Tyrie Conservative
Ed Vaizey Conservative
Peter Viggers Conservative
Theresa Villiers Conservative
Charles Walker Conservative
Ben Wallace Conservative
Nigel Waterson Conservative
Angela Watkinson Conservative
Steve Webb Liberal Democrat
Michael Weir Scottish National Party
John Whittingdale Conservative
Bill Wiggin Conservative
David Willetts Conservative
Stephen Williams Liberal Democrat
Mark Williams Liberal Democrat
Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
Roger Williams Liberal Democrat
Phil Willis Liberal Democrat
Rob Wilson Conservative
Sammy Wilson DUP
Ann Winterton Conservative
Pete Wishart Scottish National Party
Jeremy Wright Conservative
George Young Conservative
Richard Younger-Ross Liberal Democrat

Tellers

Peter Atkinson Conservative
Crispin Blunt Conservative

No: A-Z by last name

Nick Ainger Labour
Bob Ainsworth Labour
Graham Allen Labour
Janet Anderson Labour
David Anderson Labour
Hilary Armstrong Labour
Charlotte Atkins Labour
Ian Austin Labour
John Austin Labour
Adrian Bailey Labour
Vera Baird Labour
Edward Balls Labour
Gordon Banks Labour
Kevin Barron Labour
John Battle Labour
Anne Begg Labour
Stuart Bell Labour
Hilary Benn Labour
Joe Benton Labour
Clive Betts Labour
Liz Blackman Labour
Roberta Blackman-Woods Labour
Hazel Blears Labour
Bob Blizzard Labour
Ben Bradshaw Labour
Kevin Brennan Labour
Russell Brown Labour
Nick Brown Labour
Lyn Brown Labour
Des Browne Labour
Chris Bryant Labour
Colin Burgon Labour
Andy Burnham Labour
Dawn Butler Labour
Stephen Byers Labour
Liam Byrne Labour
Richard Caborn Labour
David Cairns Labour
Alan Campbell Labour
Ronnie Campbell Labour
Martin Caton Labour
Ian Cawsey Labour
Colin Challen Labour
Ben Chapman Labour
David Chaytor Labour
Michael Clapham Labour
Katy Clark Labour
David Clelland Labour
Ann Clwyd Labour
Ann Coffey Labour
Michael Connarty Labour
Frank Cook Labour
Yvette Cooper Labour
Rosie Cooper Labour
Jeremy Corbyn Labour
David Crausby Labour
Mary Creagh Labour
Jon Cruddas Labour
Ann Cryer Labour
John Cummings Labour
Tony Cunningham Labour
Alistair Darling Labour
Wayne David Labour
Ian Davidson Labour
Janet Dean Labour
John Denham Labour
Jim Devine Labour
Parmjit Dhanda Labour
Andrew Dismore Labour
Jim Dobbin Labour
Frank Dobson Labour
Frank Doran Labour
Jim Dowd Labour
David Drew Labour
Gwyneth Dunwoody Labour
Mark Durkan Social Democratic and Labour Party
Maria Eagle Labour
Angela Eagle Labour
Clive Efford Labour
Louise Ellman Labour
Jeff Ennis Labour
Bill Etherington Labour
Frank Field Labour
Mark Fisher Labour
Jim Fitzpatrick Labour
Rob Flello Labour
Caroline Flint Labour
Barbara Follett Labour
Michael Foster Labour
Mike Gapes Labour
Bruce George Labour
Neil Gerrard Labour
Ian Gibson Labour
Roger Godsiff Labour
Paul Goggins Labour
Helen Goodman Labour
Nia Griffith Labour
Nigel Griffiths Labour
John Grogan Labour
Andrew Gwynne Labour
Patrick Hall Labour
Mike Hall Labour
Fabian Hamilton Labour
David Hanson Labour
Harriet Harman Labour
Tom Harris Labour
John Healey Labour
Doug Henderson Labour
Mark Hendrick Labour
Stephen Hepburn Labour
John Heppell Labour
Sylvia Hermon UUP
Stephen Hesford Labour
David Heyes Labour
Meg Hillier Labour
Margaret Hodge Labour
Sharon Hodgson Labour
Kate Hoey Labour
Geoff Hoon Labour
Phil Hope Labour
Kelvin Hopkins Labour
Lindsay Hoyle Labour
Beverley Hughes Labour
John Hutton Labour
Adam Ingram Labour
Huw Irranca-Davies Labour
Glenda Jackson Labour
Siân James Labour
Diana R. Johnson Labour
Alan Johnson Labour
Helen Jones Labour
Martyn Jones Labour
Tessa Jowell Labour
Eric Joyce Labour
Barbara Keeley Labour
Ann Keen Labour
Alan Keen Labour
Fraser Kemp Labour
Jane Kennedy Labour
Sadiq Khan Labour
David Kidney Labour
Jim Knight Labour
Ashok Kumar Labour
Stephen Ladyman Labour
Bob Laxton Labour
Mark Lazarowicz Labour
David Lepper Labour
Ivan Lewis Labour
Martin Linton Labour
Tony Lloyd Labour
Andrew Love Labour
John MacDougall Labour
Andrew MacKinlay Labour
Denis MacShane Labour
Shahid Malik Labour
Judy Mallaber Labour
John Mann Labour
Rob Marris Labour
Gordon Marsden Labour
David Marshall Labour
Eric Martlew Labour
Thomas McAvoy Labour
Steve McCabe Labour
Chris McCafferty Labour
Kerry McCarthy Labour
Sarah McCarthy-Fry Labour
Siobhain McDonagh Labour
Pat McFadden Labour
John McFall Labour
Jim McGovern Labour
Anne McGuire Labour
Shona McIsaac Labour
Rosemary McKenna Labour
Tony McNulty Labour
Michael Meacher Labour
Alan Meale Labour
Gillian Merron Labour
Alan Milburn Labour
David Miliband Labour
Ed Miliband Labour
Andrew Miller Labour
Austin Mitchell Labour
Laura Moffatt Labour
Chris Mole Labour
Madeleine Moon Labour
Margaret Moran Labour
Jessica Morden Labour
Julie Morgan Labour
Kali Mountford Labour
George Mudie Labour
Chris Mullin Labour
Meg Munn Labour
Paul Murphy Labour
Jim Murphy Labour
Denis Murphy Labour
Doug Naysmith Labour
Dan Norris Labour
Mike O'Brien Labour
Edward O'Hara Labour
Bill Olner Labour
Sandra Osborne Labour
Albert Owen Labour
Nick Palmer Labour
Ian Pearson Labour
James Plaskitt Labour
Greg Pope Labour
Bridget Prentice Labour
Gordon Prentice Labour
John Prescott Labour
Dawn Primarolo Labour
Gwyn Prosser Labour
Ken Purchase Labour
James Purnell Labour
Jamie Reed Labour
Andy Reed Labour
Linda Riordan Labour
Chris Ruane Labour
Christine Russell Labour
Joan Ryan Labour
Martin Salter Labour
Jonathan R Shaw Labour
Barry Sheerman Labour
Jim Sheridan Labour
Siôn Simon Labour
Alan Simpson Labour
Dennis Skinner Labour
Andrew Slaughter Labour
Angela Smith Labour
Geraldine Smith Labour
Andrew Smith Labour
Jacqui Smith Labour
Anne Snelgrove Labour
Peter Soulsby Labour
Helen Southworth Labour
John Spellar Labour
Phyllis Starkey Labour
Ian Stewart Labour
Howard Stoate Labour
Graham Stringer Labour
Gisela Stuart Labour
Mark Tami Labour
David Taylor Labour
Dari Taylor Labour
Gareth Thomas Labour
Emily Thornberry Labour
Stephen Timms Labour
Paddy Tipping Labour
Mark Todd Labour
Don Touhig Labour
Jon Trickett Labour
Paul Truswell Labour
Neil Turner Labour
Desmond Turner Labour
Kitty Ussher Labour
Rudi Vis Labour
Lynda Waltho Labour
Claire Ward Labour
Robert Wareing Labour
Tom Watson Labour
Dave Watts Labour
Alan Whitehead Labour
Malcolm Wicks Labour
Betty Williams Labour
Alan Williams Labour
David Winnick Labour
Rosie Winterton Labour
Phil Woolas Labour
Tony Wright Labour
Iain Wright Labour
Anthony D Wright Labour
David Wright Labour
Derek Wyatt Labour

TheyWorkForYou

Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Bill

Votes in this debate

Division number 97 Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Bill

Aye: 228 MPs

No: 270 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Tellers

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

Division number 98 Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Bill

Aye: 225 MPs

No: 272 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Tellers

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

TheyWorkForYou