New Clause 3 — Railway Functions of Passenger Transport Executives in Scotland

Part of Orders of the Day — Railways Bill – in the House of Commons at 2:20 pm on 27 January 2005.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Greg Knight Greg Knight Shadow Minister (Environment, Food and Rural Affairs) 2:20, 27 January 2005

I rise to speak to amendment No. 64, which would add to the end of clause 5(2) the phrase

"and they shall concurrently publish in full the reasons for adopting the strategy or revised strategy."

A duty would thereby be imposed on Scottish Ministers, in preparing or revising a strategy, to publish in full their reasons for so doing.

We live in an age of openness and—I like to think—fairness, and everything that we do should at least be within the spirit of the Freedom of Information Act. The public have a right to know why decisions are made using their money in their name, and the amendment would impose a duty on Scottish Ministers to ensure that whenever they publish or change a strategy, they explain why.

I hope that the Minister will tell me and the House that my amendment is not necessary because she expects the giving of such explanations to be best practice. If she does, I shall be delighted not to pursue the matter further.