Clause 216 — Life Sentence or Imprisonment for Public Protection for Serious Offences: 18 Nov 2003: House of Commons debates

Division number 378

Lords amendment: No. 167.

Motion made, and Question put, That this House disagrees with the Lords in the said amendment.—[Mr. Heppell.]

The House divided: Ayes 332, Noes 51.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 18 November 2003, c734)

Aye: 332 MPs

No: 51 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Mrs Irene Adams Labour
Nick Ainger Labour
Bob Ainsworth Labour
Douglas Alexander Labour
Graham Allen Labour
Janet Anderson Labour
Mr Donald Anderson Labour
Hilary Armstrong Labour
Ms Candy Atherton Labour
Charlotte Atkins Labour
John Austin Labour
Adrian Bailey Labour/Co-operative
Vera Baird Labour
Mr Tony Banks Labour
Mr Harry Barnes Labour
Kevin Barron Labour
John Battle Labour
Hugh Bayley Labour
Mr Nigel Beard Labour
Margaret Beckett Labour
Mr Roy Beggs UUP
Stuart Bell Labour
Hilary Benn Labour
Mr Andrew Bennett Labour
Joe Benton Labour
Roger Berry Labour
Mr Harold Best Labour
Clive Betts Labour
Liz Blackman Labour
Hazel Blears Labour
Bob Blizzard Labour
David Blunkett Labour
Mr Paul Boateng Labour
David Borrow Labour
Mr Peter Bradley Labour
Mr Keith Bradley Labour
Ben Bradshaw Labour
Russell Brown Labour
Nick Brown Labour
Des Browne Labour
Chris Bryant Labour
Karen Buck Labour
Richard Burden Labour
Colin Burgon Labour
Andy Burnham Labour
Stephen Byers Labour
David Cairns Labour
Alan Campbell Labour
Ronnie Campbell Labour
Mrs Anne Campbell Labour
Mr Ivor Caplin Labour
Mr Roger Casale Labour
Martin Caton Labour
Colin Challen Labour
Ben Chapman Labour
David Chaytor Labour
Michael Clapham Labour
Paul Clark Labour
Dr Lynda Clark Labour
Tom Clarke Labour
Charles Clarke Labour
Mr Tony Clarke Labour
David Clelland Labour
Ann Clwyd Labour
Vernon Coaker Labour
Ann Coffey Labour
Harry Cohen Labour
Mr Tony Colman Labour
Yvette Cooper Labour
Jim Cousins Labour
Professor Ross Cranston Labour
Jon Cruddas Labour
John Cryer Labour
Ann Cryer Labour
John Cummings Labour
Dr Jack Cunningham Labour
Jim Cunningham Labour
Tony Cunningham Labour
Alistair Darling Labour
Mrs Valerie Davey Labour
Wayne David Labour
Ian Davidson Labour/Co-operative
Geraint Davies Labour
Mr Denzil Davies Labour
Mr Terry Davis Labour
Mr Hilton Dawson Labour
Janet Dean Labour
John Denham Labour
Andrew Dismore Labour
Brian H Donohoe Labour
Frank Doran Labour
Jim Dowd Labour
David Drew Labour/Co-operative
Angela Eagle Labour
Maria Eagle Labour
Mr Huw Edwards Labour
Clive Efford Labour
Louise Ellman Labour/Co-operative
Jeff Ennis Labour
Paul Farrelly Labour
Frank Field Labour
Mark Fisher Labour
Ms Lorna Fitzsimons Labour
Caroline Flint Labour
Paul Flynn Labour
Barbara Follett Labour
Michael Jabez Foster Labour
Mr Derek Foster Labour
Michael Foster Labour
Hywel Francis Labour
Mike Gapes Labour/Co-operative
Barry Gardiner Labour
Bruce George Labour
Neil Gerrard Labour
Linda Gilroy Labour/Co-operative
Roger Godsiff Labour
Paul Goggins Labour
Nigel Griffiths Labour
Mr Win Griffiths Labour
John Grogan Labour
Peter Hain Labour
Mike Hall Labour
Patrick Hall Labour
David Hamilton Labour
David Hanson Labour
Harriet Harman Labour
Tom Harris Labour
Dai Havard Labour
John Healey Labour
Mr Ivan Henderson Labour
Mark Hendrick Labour/Co-operative
Stephen Hepburn Labour
John Heppell Labour
Sylvia Hermon UUP
Stephen Hesford Labour
Patricia Hewitt Labour
David Heyes Labour
Keith Hill Labour
Margaret Hodge Labour
Phil Hope Labour/Co-operative
Kelvin Hopkins Labour
George Howarth Labour
Mr Alan Howarth Labour
Kim Howells Labour
Lindsay Hoyle Labour
Beverley Hughes Labour
Joan Humble Labour
Mr Alan Hurst Labour
John Hutton Labour
Adam Ingram Labour
Huw Irranca-Davies Labour
Mrs Helen Jackson Labour
Mr David Jamieson Labour
Alan Johnson Labour
Miss Melanie Johnson Labour
Helen Jones Labour
Lynne Jones Labour
Mr Jon Owen Jones Labour/Co-operative
Martyn Jones Labour
Tessa Jowell Labour
Eric Joyce Labour
Ann Keen Labour
Alan Keen Labour/Co-operative
Ruth Kelly Labour
Fraser Kemp Labour
Jane Kennedy Labour
Piara S Khabra Labour
David Kidney Labour
Peter Kilfoyle Labour
Ms Oona King Labour
Jim Knight Labour
Ashok Kumar Labour
Stephen Ladyman Labour
David Lammy Labour
Mrs Jackie Lawrence Labour
Bob Laxton Labour
Mark Lazarowicz Labour/Co-operative
David Lepper Labour/Co-operative
Chris Leslie Labour
Tom Levitt Labour
Ivan Lewis Labour
Mrs Helen Liddell Labour
Martin Linton Labour
Andrew Love Labour/Co-operative
Ian Lucas Labour
Mr Iain Luke Labour
Mr John Lyons Labour
John MacDougall Labour
Andrew MacKinlay Labour
Denis MacShane Labour
Fiona Mactaggart Labour
Khalid Mahmood Labour
Mrs Alice Mahon Labour
Judy Mallaber Labour
John Mann Labour
Rob Marris Labour
Gordon Marsden Labour
Dr Jim Marshall Labour
David Marshall Labour
Eric Martlew Labour
Thomas McAvoy Labour/Co-operative
Steve McCabe Labour
Ian McCartney Labour
Siobhain McDonagh Labour
John McFall Labour/Co-operative
Anne McGuire Labour
Shona McIsaac Labour
Ann McKechin Labour
Tony McNulty Labour
Mr John McWilliam Labour
Gillian Merron Labour
Alun Michael Labour/Co-operative
Alan Milburn Labour
David Miliband Labour
Andrew Miller Labour
Austin Mitchell Labour
Laura Moffatt Labour
Chris Mole Labour
Margaret Moran Labour
Julie Morgan Labour
Elliot Morley Labour
Ms Estelle Morris Labour
Kali Mountford Labour
George Mudie Labour
Chris Mullin Labour
Meg Munn Labour/Co-operative
Denis Murphy Labour
Paul Murphy Labour
Jim Murphy Labour
Doug Naysmith Labour/Co-operative
Dan Norris Labour
Mike O'Brien Labour
Mr Martin O'Neill Labour
Mrs Diana Organ Labour
Sandra Osborne Labour
Albert Owen Labour
Nick Palmer Labour
Ian Pearson Labour
Ms Linda Perham Labour
Mrs Anne Picking Labour
Mr Colin Pickthall Labour
Mr Peter Pike Labour
James Plaskitt Labour
Mr Kerry Pollard Labour
Mr Chris Pond Labour
Greg Pope Labour
Steve Pound Labour
Gordon Prentice Labour
Bridget Prentice Labour
Dawn Primarolo Labour
Gwyn Prosser Labour
Ken Purchase Labour/Co-operative
James Purnell Labour
Ms Joyce Quin Labour
Mr Lawrie Quinn Labour
Bill Rammell Labour
Nick Raynsford Labour
John Robertson Labour
Geoffrey Robinson Labour
Mrs Barbara Roche Labour
Mr Ernie Ross Labour
Frank Roy Labour
Chris Ruane Labour
Joan Ruddock Labour
Christine Russell Labour
Joan Ryan Labour
Martin Salter Labour
Mohammad Sarwar Labour
Mr Malcolm Savidge Labour
Mr Phil Sawford Labour
Jonathan R Shaw Labour
Barry Sheerman Labour/Co-operative
Jim Sheridan Labour
Ms Debra Shipley Labour
Marsha Singh Labour
Dennis Skinner Labour
Andrew Smith Labour
Jacqui Smith Labour
Angela Smith Labour/Co-operative
John Smith Labour
Mr Clive Soley Labour
Helen Southworth Labour
John Spellar Labour
Rachel Squire Labour
Phyllis Starkey Labour
Mr Gerry Steinberg Labour
Mr George Stevenson Labour
Ian Stewart Labour
Mr David Stewart Labour
Mr Paul Stinchcombe Labour
Howard Stoate Labour
Gavin Strang Labour
Graham Stringer Labour
Gisela Stuart Labour
Mark Tami Labour
David Taylor Labour/Co-operative
Dari Taylor Labour
Mrs Ann Taylor Labour
Mr Gareth Thomas Labour
Gareth Thomas Labour
Stephen Timms Labour
Paddy Tipping Labour
Don Touhig Labour/Co-operative
Jon Trickett Labour
Paul Truswell Labour
Mr Dennis Turner Labour/Co-operative
Neil Turner Labour
Stephen Twigg Labour
Mr Bill Tynan Labour
Keith Vaz Labour
Rudi Vis Labour
Joan Walley Labour
Claire Ward Labour
Robert Wareing Labour
Tom Watson Labour
Dave Watts Labour
Mr Brian White Labour
Alan Whitehead Labour
Malcolm Wicks Labour
Betty Williams Labour
Alan Williams Labour
Michael Wills Labour
David Winnick Labour
Rosie Winterton Labour
Mike Wood Labour
Shaun Woodward Labour
Phil Woolas Labour
Mr Tony Worthington Labour
Mr Jimmy Wray Labour
Tony Wright Labour
David Wright Labour
Anthony D Wright Labour

Tellers

Jim Fitzpatrick Labour
Derek Twigg Labour

No: A-Z by last name

Mr Richard Allan Liberal Democrat
Norman Baker Liberal Democrat
John Barrett Liberal Democrat
Alan Beith Liberal Democrat
Tom Brake Liberal Democrat
Colin Breed Liberal Democrat
Annette Brooke Liberal Democrat
Malcolm Bruce Liberal Democrat
Mr John Burnett Liberal Democrat
Paul Burstow Liberal Democrat
Vincent Cable Liberal Democrat
Patsy Calton Liberal Democrat
Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
Mr David Chidgey Liberal Democrat
Mr Brian Cotter Liberal Democrat
Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
Ms Sue Doughty Liberal Democrat
Don Foster Liberal Democrat
Sandra Gidley Liberal Democrat
Mr Matthew Green Liberal Democrat
Nick Harvey Liberal Democrat
David Heath Liberal Democrat
Paul Holmes Liberal Democrat
Simon Hughes Liberal Democrat
Mr Nigel Jones Liberal Democrat
Paul Keetch Liberal Democrat
Charles Kennedy Liberal Democrat
Mr Archy Kirkwood Liberal Democrat
Norman Lamb Liberal Democrat
David Laws Liberal Democrat
Elfyn Llwyd Plaid Cymru
Mr Paul Marsden Liberal Democrat
Michael Moore Liberal Democrat
Lembit Öpik Liberal Democrat
Adam Price Plaid Cymru
Alan Reid Liberal Democrat
Mr David Rendel Liberal Democrat
Bob Russell Liberal Democrat
Adrian Sanders Liberal Democrat
Robert Smith Liberal Democrat
Matthew Taylor Liberal Democrat
Richard Taylor Independent
Sarah Teather Liberal Democrat
Mr Simon Thomas Plaid Cymru
John Thurso Liberal Democrat
Dr Jenny Tonge Liberal Democrat
Mr Paul Tyler Liberal Democrat
Steve Webb Liberal Democrat
Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
Roger Williams Liberal Democrat
Phil Willis Liberal Democrat

Tellers

Andrew Stunell Liberal Democrat
Richard Younger-Ross Liberal Democrat

Link to this vote In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 18 November 2003, c734)

Question accordingly agreed to.

Lords amendment disagreed to.

Lords amendments Nos. 173 and 235 disagreed to.

Lords amendments Nos. 140 to 166, 168 to 172 and 174 to 202 agreed to.

Link to this item In context Individually
Tweet Share
Hansard source (Citation: HC Deb, 18 November 2003, c734)

TheyWorkForYou

Clause 216 — Life Sentence or Imprisonment for Public Protection for Serious Offences

Votes in this debate

Division number 378 Criminal Justice Bill — Clause 216 — Life Sentence or Imprisonment for Public Protection for Serious Offences

Aye: 332 MPs

No: 51 MPs

Aye: A-Z by last name

Tellers

No: A-Z by last name

Tellers

TheyWorkForYou