Votes in this debate
Division number 267
Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Bill — Allow earlier rights of appeal — rejected
Aye: 58 MPs
No: 362 MPs
Ayes: A-Z by last name
- Diane Abbott Labour
- Mr Richard Allan Liberal Democrat
- Norman Baker Liberal Democrat
- John Barrett Liberal Democrat
- Alan Beith Liberal Democrat
- Peter Bottomley Conservative
- Tom Brake Liberal Democrat
- Colin Breed Liberal Democrat
- Malcolm Bruce Liberal Democrat
- Mr John Burnett Liberal Democrat
- Paul Burstow Liberal Democrat
- Vincent Cable Liberal Democrat
- Menzies Campbell Liberal Democrat
- Alistair Carmichael Liberal Democrat
- Mr David Chidgey Liberal Democrat
- Jeremy Corbyn Labour
- Mr Brian Cotter Liberal Democrat
- Edward Davey Liberal Democrat
- Ms Sue Doughty Liberal Democrat
- Ms Annabelle Ewing Scottish National Party
- Don Foster Liberal Democrat
- Andrew George Liberal Democrat
- Sandra Gidley Liberal Democrat
- Mr Matthew Green Liberal Democrat
- Mike Hancock Liberal Democrat
- Nick Harvey Liberal Democrat
- David Heath Liberal Democrat
- Douglas Hogg Conservative
- Paul Holmes Liberal Democrat
- Simon Hughes Liberal Democrat
- Mr Nigel Jones Liberal Democrat
- Charles Kennedy Liberal Democrat
- Mr Archy Kirkwood Liberal Democrat
- Norman Lamb Liberal Democrat
- David Laws Liberal Democrat
- Elfyn Llwyd Plaid Cymru
- Mr Paul Marsden Liberal Democrat
- Michael Moore Liberal Democrat
- Mark Oaten Liberal Democrat
- John Pugh Liberal Democrat
- Alan Reid Liberal Democrat
- Mr David Rendel Liberal Democrat
- Angus Robertson Scottish National Party
- Alex Salmond Scottish National Party
- Adrian Sanders Liberal Democrat
- Robert Smith Liberal Democrat
- Andrew Stunell Liberal Democrat
- Matthew Taylor Liberal Democrat
- Richard Taylor Independent
- Mr Simon Thomas Plaid Cymru
- Dr Jenny Tonge Liberal Democrat
- Mr Paul Tyler Liberal Democrat
- Steve Webb Liberal Democrat
- Michael Weir Scottish National Party
- Hywel Williams Plaid Cymru
- Phil Willis Liberal Democrat
- Pete Wishart Scottish National Party
- Richard Younger-Ross Liberal Democrat
Tellers
- Annette Brooke Liberal Democrat
- Bob Russell Liberal Democrat
Nos: A-Z by last name
- Mrs Irene Adams Labour
- Nick Ainger Labour
- Bob Ainsworth Labour
- Douglas Alexander Labour
- Graham Allen Labour
- Mr Donald Anderson Labour
- Janet Anderson Labour
- Hilary Armstrong Labour
- Charlotte Atkins Labour
- Adrian Bailey Labour/Co-operative
- Vera Baird Labour
- Mr Tony Banks Labour
- Kevin Barron Labour
- John Battle Labour
- Mr Nigel Beard Labour
- Margaret Beckett Labour
- Anne Begg Labour
- Mr Roy Beggs UUP
- Stuart Bell Labour
- Hilary Benn Labour
- Joe Benton Labour
- Roger Berry Labour
- Clive Betts Labour
- Liz Blackman Labour
- Hazel Blears Labour
- Bob Blizzard Labour
- David Blunkett Labour
- Mr Paul Boateng Labour
- Mr Peter Bradley Labour
- Mr Keith Bradley Labour
- Ben Bradshaw Labour
- Julian Brazier Conservative
- Kevin Brennan Labour
- Nick Brown Labour
- Russell Brown Labour
- Des Browne Labour
- Chris Bryant Labour
- Karen Buck Labour
- Richard Burden Labour
- Colin Burgon Labour
- Andy Burnham Labour
- David Burnside UUP
- John Butterfill Conservative
- David Cairns Labour
- Gregory Campbell DUP
- Ronnie Campbell Labour
- Mrs Anne Campbell Labour
- Alan Campbell Labour
- Mr Ivor Caplin Labour
- Mr Roger Casale Labour
- Martin Caton Labour
- Ian Cawsey Labour
- Colin Challen Labour
- Ben Chapman Labour
- David Chaytor Labour
- Michael Clapham Labour
- Dr Lynda Clark Labour
- Paul Clark Labour
- Tom Clarke Labour
- Charles Clarke Labour
- Mr Tony Clarke Labour
- David Clelland Labour
- Ann Clwyd Labour
- Vernon Coaker Labour
- Ann Coffey Labour
- Harry Cohen Labour
- Michael Connarty Labour
- Frank Cook Labour
- Robin Cook Labour
- Yvette Cooper Labour
- Ms Jean Corston Labour
- Jim Cousins Labour
- Mr Tom Cox Labour
- Professor Ross Cranston Labour
- David Crausby Labour
- Jon Cruddas Labour
- Ann Cryer Labour
- John Cummings Labour
- Tony Cunningham Labour
- Jim Cunningham Labour
- Mr Tam Dalyell Labour
- Alistair Darling Labour
- Mrs Valerie Davey Labour
- Wayne David Labour
- Ian Davidson Labour/Co-operative
- Geraint Davies Labour
- Mr Hilton Dawson Labour
- Janet Dean Labour
- John Denham Labour
- Parmjit Dhanda Labour
- Andrew Dismore Labour
- Jim Dobbin Labour/Co-operative
- Frank Dobson Labour
- Brian H Donohoe Labour
- Jim Dowd Labour
- David Drew Labour/Co-operative
- Angela Eagle Labour
- Maria Eagle Labour
- Mr Huw Edwards Labour
- Louise Ellman Labour/Co-operative
- Jeff Ennis Labour
- Paul Farrelly Labour
- Mark Fisher Labour
- Jim Fitzpatrick Labour
- Ms Lorna Fitzsimons Labour
- Caroline Flint Labour
- Mr Adrian Flook Conservative
- Paul Flynn Labour
- Barbara Follett Labour
- Michael Foster Labour
- Mr Derek Foster Labour
- Michael Jabez Foster Labour
- Mr George Foulkes Labour/Co-operative
- Hywel Francis Labour
- Mike Gapes Labour/Co-operative
- Barry Gardiner Labour
- Bruce George Labour
- Ian Gibson Labour
- Dame Cheryl Gillan Conservative
- Linda Gilroy Labour/Co-operative
- Roger Godsiff Labour
- Paul Goggins Labour
- Paul Goodman Conservative
- James Gray Conservative
- Dominic Grieve Conservative
- Nigel Griffiths Labour
- Mr Win Griffiths Labour
- Ms Jane Griffiths Labour
- John Grogan Labour
- Peter Hain Labour
- Mike Hall Labour
- David Hamilton Labour
- Fabian Hamilton Labour
- David Hanson Labour
- Harriet Harman Labour
- Tom Harris Labour
- John Hayes Conservative
- John Healey Labour
- Doug Henderson Labour
- Mr Ivan Henderson Labour
- Mark Hendrick Labour/Co-operative
- Charles Hendry Conservative
- Stephen Hepburn Labour
- John Heppell Labour
- Sylvia Hermon UUP
- Stephen Hesford Labour
- David Heyes Labour
- Keith Hill Labour
- Mr David Hinchliffe Labour
- Mark Hoban Conservative
- Margaret Hodge Labour
- Kate Hoey Labour
- Jimmy Hood Labour
- Geoff Hoon Labour
- Phil Hope Labour/Co-operative
- Kelvin Hopkins Labour
- George Howarth Labour
- Mr Alan Howarth Labour
- Kim Howells Labour
- Mr Kevin Hughes Labour
- Beverley Hughes Labour
- Joan Humble Labour
- John Hutton Labour
- Brian Iddon Labour
- Huw Irranca-Davies Labour
- Mr David Jamieson Labour
- Brian Jenkins Labour
- Alan Johnson Labour
- Helen Jones Labour
- Kevan Jones Labour
- Martyn Jones Labour
- Mr Jon Owen Jones Labour/Co-operative
- Tessa Jowell Labour
- Eric Joyce Labour
- Sally Keeble Labour
- Alan Keen Labour/Co-operative
- Ann Keen Labour
- Ruth Kelly Labour
- Fraser Kemp Labour
- Jane Kennedy Labour
- Piara S Khabra Labour
- David Kidney Labour
- Peter Kilfoyle Labour
- Julie Kirkbride Conservative
- Jim Knight Labour
- Ashok Kumar Labour
- Stephen Ladyman Labour
- David Lammy Labour
- Mrs Jackie Lawrence Labour
- Mark Lazarowicz Labour/Co-operative
- David Lepper Labour/Co-operative
- Chris Leslie Labour
- Tom Levitt Labour
- Mr Terry Lewis Labour
- Ivan Lewis Labour
- Julian Lewis Conservative
- Mrs Helen Liddell Labour
- Ian Liddell-Grainger Conservative
- David Lidington Conservative
- Martin Linton Labour
- Tony Lloyd Labour
- Andrew Love Labour/Co-operative
- Ian Lucas Labour
- Peter Luff Conservative
- Mr Iain Luke Labour
- Mr John Lyons Labour
- Mr Calum MacDonald Labour
- Andrew MacKay Conservative
- Andrew MacKinlay Labour
- Denis MacShane Labour
- Khalid Mahmood Labour
- Judy Mallaber Labour
- Mr Peter Mandelson Labour
- John Mann Labour
- Rob Marris Labour
- Gordon Marsden Labour
- Eric Martlew Labour
- Dr Brian Mawhinney Conservative
- Steve McCabe Labour
- Chris McCafferty Labour
- Ian McCartney Labour
- Siobhain McDonagh Labour
- John McFall Labour/Co-operative
- Anne McGuire Labour
- Anne McIntosh Conservative
- Shona McIsaac Labour
- Ann McKechin Labour
- Rosemary McKenna Labour
- Patrick McLoughlin Conservative
- Tony McNulty Labour
- Mr Tony McWalter Labour/Co-operative
- Michael Meacher Labour
- Alan Meale Labour
- Patrick Mercer Conservative
- Gillian Merron Labour
- Alun Michael Labour/Co-operative
- Alan Milburn Labour
- David Miliband Labour
- Andrew Miller Labour
- Andrew Mitchell Conservative
- Laura Moffatt Labour
- Dr Lewis Moonie Labour/Co-operative
- Julie Morgan Labour
- Elliot Morley Labour
- Ms Estelle Morris Labour
- Kali Mountford Labour
- Chris Mullin Labour
- Meg Munn Labour/Co-operative
- Jim Murphy Labour
- Paul Murphy Labour
- Denis Murphy Labour
- Andrew Murrison Conservative
- Doug Naysmith Labour/Co-operative
- Mr Bill O'Brien Labour
- Edward O'Hara Labour
- Mr Martin O'Neill Labour
- Mrs Diana Organ Labour
- Sandra Osborne Labour
- Albert Owen Labour
- Nick Palmer Labour
- Ian Pearson Labour
- Mrs Anne Picking Labour
- Mr Colin Pickthall Labour
- Mr Peter Pike Labour
- James Plaskitt Labour
- Mr Chris Pond Labour
- Greg Pope Labour
- Steve Pound Labour
- Bridget Prentice Labour
- Gordon Prentice Labour
- Dawn Primarolo Labour
- Gwyn Prosser Labour
- Ken Purchase Labour/Co-operative
- James Purnell Labour
- Ms Joyce Quin Labour
- Mr Lawrie Quinn Labour
- Bill Rammell Labour
- Mr Syd Rapson Labour
- John Redwood Conservative
- Andy Reed Labour/Co-operative
- John Reid Labour
- Laurence Robertson Conservative
- John Robertson Labour
- Peter Robinson DUP
- Geoffrey Robinson Labour
- Mrs Barbara Roche Labour
- Terry Rooney Labour
- Mr Ernie Ross Labour
- Frank Roy Labour
- Chris Ruane Labour
- Christine Russell Labour
- Joan Ryan Labour
- Mr Malcolm Savidge Labour
- Mr Phil Sawford Labour
- Jonathan R Shaw Labour
- Jim Sheridan Labour
- Clare Short Labour
- Dennis Skinner Labour
- Andrew Smith Labour
- John Smith Labour
- Geraldine Smith Labour
- Mr Llew Smith Labour
- Jacqui Smith Labour
- Martin Smyth UUP
- Mr Clive Soley Labour
- Helen Southworth Labour
- Michael Spicer Conservative
- Rachel Squire Labour
- Phyllis Starkey Labour
- Mr Gerry Steinberg Labour
- Mr George Stevenson Labour
- Ian Stewart Labour
- Mr David Stewart Labour
- Mr Paul Stinchcombe Labour
- Howard Stoate Labour
- Gavin Strang Labour
- Graham Stringer Labour
- Gisela Stuart Labour
- Gerry Sutcliffe Labour
- Desmond Swayne Conservative
- Hugo Swire Conservative
- Robert Syms Conservative
- Mark Tami Labour
- Dari Taylor Labour
- David Taylor Labour/Co-operative
- Mrs Ann Taylor Labour
- Gareth Thomas Labour
- Paddy Tipping Labour
- Mark Todd Labour
- Don Touhig Labour/Co-operative
- Jon Trickett Labour
- Paul Truswell Labour
- Mr Dennis Turner Labour/Co-operative
- Andrew Turner Conservative
- Neil Turner Labour
- Desmond Turner Labour
- Derek Twigg Labour
- Stephen Twigg Labour
- Mr Bill Tynan Labour
- Keith Vaz Labour
- Joan Walley Labour
- Claire Ward Labour
- Robert Wareing Labour
- Angela Watkinson Conservative
- Dave Watts Labour
- Alan Whitehead Labour
- John Whittingdale Conservative
- Malcolm Wicks Labour
- Bill Wiggin Conservative
- Alan Williams Labour
- Betty Williams Labour
- David Wilshire Conservative
- Mr Brian Wilson Labour
- Rosie Winterton Labour
- Ann Winterton Conservative
- Nicholas Winterton Conservative
- Shaun Woodward Labour
- Mr Tony Worthington Labour
- Mr Jimmy Wray Labour
- David Wright Labour
- Anthony D Wright Labour
- Derek Wyatt Labour
Tellers
- Angela Smith Labour/Co-operative
- Phil Woolas Labour
Absent: 234 MPs
Abstained: 1 MP
Absents: A-Z by last name
- Gerry Adams Sinn Féin
- Peter Ainsworth Conservative
- Sir David Amess Conservative
- Michael Ancram Conservative
- James Arbuthnot Conservative
- Ms Candy Atherton Labour
- Mr David Atkinson Conservative
- Peter Atkinson Conservative
- John Austin Labour
- Richard Bacon Conservative
- Tony Baldry Conservative
- Gregory Barker Conservative
- Mr Harry Barnes Labour
- John Baron Conservative
- Hugh Bayley Labour
- Henry Bellingham Conservative
- Mr Andrew Bennett Labour
- John Bercow Conservative
- Paul Beresford Conservative
- Mr Harold Best Labour
- Tony Blair Labour
- Crispin Blunt Conservative
- David Borrow Labour
- Tim Boswell Conservative
- Mrs Virginia Bottomley Conservative
- Graham Brady Conservative
- Gordon Brown Labour
- Angela Browning Conservative
- Simon Burns Conservative
- Alistair Burt Conservative
- Stephen Byers Labour
- Richard Caborn Labour
- Patsy Calton Liberal Democrat
- David Cameron Conservative
- Bill Cash Conservative
- Sir Sydney Chapman Conservative
- Christopher Chope Conservative
- James Clappison Conservative
- Ms Helen Clark Labour
- Kenneth Clarke Conservative
- Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Conservative
- Mr Iain Coleman Labour
- Mr Tim Collins Conservative
- Mr Tony Colman Labour
- Derek Conway Conservative
- Patrick Cormack Conservative
- Mr James Cran Conservative
- John Cryer Labour
- Dr Jack Cunningham Labour
- David Curry Conservative
- Claire Curtis-Thomas Labour
- Mr Paul Daisley Labour
- Quentin Davies Conservative
- Mr Denzil Davies Labour
- David Davis Conservative
- Mr Terry Davis Labour
- Jonathan Djanogly Conservative
- Nigel Dodds DUP
- Pat Doherty Sinn Féin
- Jeffrey M. Donaldson UUP
- Frank Doran Labour
- Stephen Dorrell Conservative
- Ms Julia Drown Labour
- Alan Duncan Conservative
- Mr Peter Duncan Conservative
- Iain Duncan Smith Conservative
- Gwyneth Dunwoody Labour
- Clive Efford Labour
- Bill Etherington Labour
- Nigel Evans Conservative
- Michael Fabricant Conservative
- Michael Fallon Conservative
- Mark Field Conservative
- Frank Field Labour
- Mr Howard Flight Conservative
- Eric Forth Conservative
- Liam Fox Conservative
- Mark Francois Conservative
- Roger Gale Conservative
- George Galloway Labour
- Edward Garnier Conservative
- Neil Gerrard Labour
- Nick Gibb Conservative
- Michelle Gildernew Sinn Féin
- Chris Grayling Conservative
- Damian Green Conservative
- John Greenway Conservative
- John Gummer Conservative
- William Hague Conservative
- Patrick Hall Labour
- Philip Hammond Conservative
- Evan Harris Liberal Democrat
- Alan Haselhurst Deputy Speaker
- Dai Havard Labour
- Mr Nick Hawkins Conservative
- Sylvia Heal Deputy Speaker
- Oliver Heald Conservative
- David Heathcoat-Amory Conservative
- Patricia Hewitt Labour
- John Horam Conservative
- Michael Howard Conservative
- Gerald Howarth Conservative
- Lindsay Hoyle Labour
- Mr John Hume Social Democratic and Labour Party
- Mr Andrew Hunter Conservative
- Mr Alan Hurst Labour
- Eric Illsley Labour
- Adam Ingram Labour
- Michael Jack Conservative
- Glenda Jackson Labour
- Robert Jackson Conservative
- Bernard Jenkin Conservative
- Miss Melanie Johnson Labour
- Boris Johnson Conservative
- Lynne Jones Labour
- Gerald Kaufman Labour
- Paul Keetch Liberal Democrat
- Robert Key Conservative
- Ms Oona King Labour
- Mr Andy King Labour
- Greg Knight Conservative
- Eleanor Laing Conservative
- Jacqui Lait Conservative
- Andrew Lansley Conservative
- Bob Laxton Labour
- Edward Leigh Conservative
- Oliver Letwin Conservative
- Peter Lilley Conservative
- Michael Lord Deputy Speaker
- Tim Loughton Conservative
- John MacDougall Labour
- David Maclean Conservative
- Fiona Mactaggart Labour
- Mrs Alice Mahon Labour
- Humfrey Malins Conservative
- Mr Seamus Mallon Social Democratic and Labour Party
- John Maples Conservative
- David Marshall Labour
- Dr Jim Marshall Labour
- Robert Marshall-Andrews Labour
- Michael Martin Speaker
- Michael Mates Conservative
- Francis Maude Conservative
- Theresa May Conservative
- Thomas McAvoy Labour/Co-operative
- John Martin McDonnell Labour
- Eddie McGrady Social Democratic and Labour Party
- Martin McGuinness Sinn Féin
- Mr Kevin McNamara Labour
- Mr John McWilliam Labour
- Austin Mitchell Labour
- Chris Mole Labour
- Margaret Moran Labour
- Malcolm Moss Conservative
- George Mudie Labour
- Mr Archie Norman Conservative
- Dan Norris Labour
- Mike O'Brien Labour
- Stephen O'Brien Conservative
- Bill Olner Labour
- Lembit Öpik Liberal Democrat
- George Osborne Conservative
- Richard Ottaway Conservative
- Mr Richard Page Conservative
- James Paice Conservative
- Ian Paisley DUP
- Owen Paterson Conservative
- Ms Linda Perham Labour
- Eric Pickles Conservative
- Mr Kerry Pollard Labour
- Mr Michael Portillo Conservative
- John Prescott Labour
- Adam Price Plaid Cymru
- Mark Prisk Conservative
- John Randall Conservative
- Nick Raynsford Labour
- Andrew Robathan Conservative
- Hugh Robertson Conservative
- Iris Robinson DUP
- Mrs Marion Roe Conservative
- Andrew Rosindell Conservative
- Joan Ruddock Labour
- David Ruffley Conservative
- Martin Salter Labour
- Mohammad Sarwar Labour
- Mr Jonathan Sayeed Conservative
- Mr Brian Sedgemore Labour
- Andrew Selous Conservative
- Barry Sheerman Labour/Co-operative
- Mrs Gillian Shephard Conservative
- Richard Shepherd Conservative
- Ms Debra Shipley Labour
- Mark Simmonds Conservative
- Siôn Simon Labour
- Alan Simpson Labour
- Keith Simpson Conservative
- Marsha Singh Labour
- Mr Chris Smith Labour
- Nicholas Soames Conservative
- John Spellar Labour
- Caroline Spelman Conservative
- Bob Spink Conservative
- Richard Spring Conservative
- John Stanley Conservative
- Anthony Steen Conservative
- Jack Straw Labour
- Gary Streeter Conservative
- Peter Tapsell Conservative
- Ian Taylor Conservative
- Mr Teddy Taylor Conservative
- Mr John Taylor Conservative
- Mr Gareth Thomas Labour
- John Thurso Liberal Democrat
- Stephen Timms Labour
- David Tredinnick Conservative
- Mr Michael Trend Conservative
- Rt Hon David Trimble UUP
- Andrew Tyrie Conservative
- Peter Viggers Conservative
- Rudi Vis Labour
- Robert Walter Conservative
- Nigel Waterson Conservative
- Tom Watson Labour
- Mr Brian White Labour
- Ann Widdecombe Conservative
- Mr John Wilkinson Conservative
- David Willetts Conservative
- Roger Williams Liberal Democrat
- Michael Wills Labour
- David Winnick Labour
- Mike Wood Labour
- Tony Wright Labour
- Tim Yeo Conservative
- George Young Conservative
Abstaineds: A-Z by last name
- Mrs Helen Jackson Labour
Question accordingly negatived.
Amendments made: No. 228, in page 44, line 20, after "decision", insert "("the new decision")".
No. 229, in page 44, line 27, leave out—
'the person is seeking to appeal'
and insert—
'the new decision responds to a request or application which the person made'.
No. 230, in page 44, line 30, leave out "has" and insert "had".
No. 231, in page 44, line 30, leave out "seeking to appeal" and insert—
'making the request or application'.
No. 232, in page 45, line 3, leave out subsection (4).
No. 233, in page 45, line 20, at end insert—
'or since a requirement under section 98 was imposed'.—[Mr. Jim Murphy.]