Community Charge

Oral Answers to Questions — Scotland – in the House of Commons at 12:00 am on 5 July 1989.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mr David Harris Mr David Harris , St Ives 12:00, 5 July 1989

To ask the Secretary of State for Scotland what proportion of single parents in Scotland are gaining from the introduction of the community charge.

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

It is estimated that some 80 per cent. of single parents are better off under the community charge than they would be under the domestic rating system.

Photo of Mr David Harris Mr David Harris , St Ives

I welcome that answer, but does my right hon. and learned Friend agree that an even higher percentage—85 per cent.—of pensioners stand to benefit from the introduction of the community charge? Do not those two sets of figures amount to further evidence of the inherent fairness of the community charge compared with the present rating system?

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

That is undoubtedly true. It is also particularly welcome because single pensioners and single parents can be found among those with the lowest incomes in our society. The fact that they overwhelmingly benefit as a result of the change in the system of local taxation is, as my hon. Friend says, another vindication of that change.

Photo of Mr Dick Douglas Mr Dick Douglas , Dunfermline West

Will the Minister have a care about his use of words? The question was about gaining. How can he suggest that single parents or anyone on a low income will gain from the imposition of the poll tax? Will he also consider the huge cost of the tax to Scotland? It costs £30 million to £40 million more than the rates. What a burden that is, and what an intrusion it is on people's civil liberties.

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

I should have thought that the hon. Gentleman with his oft-proclaimed interest in the well-being of the poorer sections of our community would be the first, if he wished to be seen as an objective commentator on these matters, to welcome the fact that 85 per cent. of single pensioners and 80 per cent. of single parents pay less now than they would be paying if domestic rates were still in force.

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

The hon. Gentleman may not like the facts, but he will have to live with them.

Photo of Mr Bill Walker Mr Bill Walker , North Tayside

Does my right hon. and learned Friend agree that single parents in Dundee are not getting the full benefit and advantage of the community charge because since 1983 Dundee district council has paid the salary of Mr. Jim White, a full-time official of NALGO, who brought about the strike and has caused terrible inconvenience to single parent? Is that not a further example of why the community charge is far higher than it should be, and a factor which may be prevalent throughout Scotland?

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

Undoubtedly, factors of the kind to which my hon. Friend refers have led to the consequences that he has described. I should have thought that anyone interested in the well-being of the community would wish to discourage any action by local authority officials or others which would have that effect. The vast majority of local authority officials are carrying out their responsibilities diligently and with due consideration for the important matters to which my hon. Friend has referred.

Photo of Mr John Maxton Mr John Maxton , Glasgow Cathcart

Is not the only reason why single parents are marginally better off this year than they were last year the iniquitous 20 per cent. minimum payment that the Government imposed on those who are hardest up in our society? If the Secretary of State is so keen on statistics, why does he not tell us the percentage of people earning more than £25,000 per year who are considerably better off as a result of the poll tax?

Photo of Malcolm Rifkind Malcolm Rifkind Secretary of State for Scottish Office

I am grateful to the hon. Member for Glasgow, Cathcart (Mr. Maxton) for rebuking the hon. Member for Dunfermline, West (Mr. Douglas) and confirming that single parents and single pensioners are better off. That is the most eloquent denunciation yet of the nonsense that we have heard from some Opposition M embers.