Kilbrandon Report

Oral Answers to Questions — Wales – in the House of Commons at 12:00 am on 29 July 1974.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mr Gwynoro Jones Mr Gwynoro Jones , Carmarthen 12:00, 29 July 1974

asked the Secretary of State for Wales when he expects to conclude discussions with the interested parties in Wales on the Kilbrandon Report.

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

I expect these consultations to be completed by about the middle of August.

Photo of Mr Gwynoro Jones Mr Gwynoro Jones , Carmarthen

Will my right hon. and learned Friend accept that Labour Members look forward to the Government's proposals in the White Paper which will enable us to make it clear to the people of Wales that since the Conservative Opposition have totally turned their back on any form of elected body for Wales those who wish to see further advance and the creation of an elected assembly will have to support the Labour Party in the forthcoming election, whenever that may be?

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

My hon. and learned Friend is correct. The Conservatives have offered nothing of substance by way of worthwhile devolution. Only the Labour Government can bring some form of devolution to Wales.

Photo of Mr Ian Grist Mr Ian Grist , Cardiff North

Will the right hon. and learned Gentleman confirm what he said before the last election: that he is in favour of a legislative assembly for Wales?

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

The hon. Member is completely misinformed.

Photo of Mr Dafydd Elis Thomas Mr Dafydd Elis Thomas , Merioneth

Does the right hon. and learned Gentleman accept the view of our party that whereas we agree that only a Labour Government will implement devolution, it is equally true that that will not happen unless there is substantial pressure on the Government from Plaid Cymru and the SNP? Does he agree that the Government would not have had a majority in a number of important votes in the House on vital legislation if they had not had the support of our party?

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

I am not sure whether the hon. Member can recall where the parliamentary pressure originally came from. I remind him that it was the Labour Government which set up the Kilbrandon Commission, a move which was ridiculed by members of Plaid Cymru at the time. When the Labour Government were fighting for their lives in a crucial vote on the debate on the Queen's Speech, the hon. Member and his hon. Friends voted against us. I shall be reminding him and Wales constantly of that in the coming months.

Photo of Mr Nicholas Edwards Mr Nicholas Edwards , Pembroke

Is it the Minister's normal practice to comment on the views of a party when he has invited that party to present its views to him next day? Would it not have been better to have waited until he heard what we had to say?

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

I have had the advantage of reading what emerged from the Conservative Party conference at Llandrindod Wells. Unless there is a substantial improvement in the forthcoming consultations, Wales will be deeply disappointed but not surprised at the Conservative Party.

Photo of Mr Emlyn Hooson Mr Emlyn Hooson , Montgomery

Is not the Secretary of State being less than magnanimous to the hon. Member for Merioneth (Mr. Thomas)? Is it not the case that he and the hon. Member for Caernarvon (Mr. Wigley) have supported the Government in almost every Division in this Parliament?

Photo of Sir John Morris Sir John Morris Secretary of State for Wales

I am always grateful for support for the enlightened policies put forward by the Government. The two hon. Members have supported the Government on many occasions, but at the end of the day the Government can be effective only if they have a sufficient number of supporters in the House of Commons and the two hon. Members cannot be counted among that number. The people of Wales will therefore have to decide whether they want devolution, and the only way to get it is through a Labour Government.