Oral Answers to Questions — India. – in the House of Commons at on 5 June 1939.
Mr Wilfred Paling
, Wentworth
asked the Prime Minister whether he has any statement to make with regard to the situation in China?
Mr Robert Gibson
, Greenock
asked the Prime Minister whether he has any statement to make regarding the position in China generally, and in the international settlements in particular; and what steps the Government are taking to safeguard the lives and interests of British subjects in these areas?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
Some fighting has been proceeding in Central China in the Han River area, but the general line held by both sides remains the same. The general situation in the International Settlement at Shanghai remains substantially unchanged. There has been no reduction in the numbers of the landing parties at Kulangsu and negotiations for a settlement there continue.
Mr Philip Noel-Baker
, Derby
Are the British and American marines still on land at Kulangsu?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
Yes, Sir.
Mr John Morgan
, Doncaster
Has the right hon. Gentleman any information with regard to the Japanese enterprise at Kalgan and with regard to the two British officers held there?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
I have had some recent information on that subject. I understand that the Chinese Secretary to the British Embassy and the British military liaison officer are returning to Peking and were expected to get back there yesterday with the latest news. When I have the latest news, I will communicate it to the hon. Member and to the House.
Mr John Morgan
, Doncaster
Has any representation of any kind been made to the Japanese Government?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
Yes, Sir. The whole matter has been taken up with the Japanese military authorities.
Sir Nairne Stewart Sandeman:
asked the Prime Minister whether he is aware that the Japanese naval mission at Tsingtao now require landing permits for each separate bill of lading in respect of goods shipped in British vessels; that the cargoes have to be stored for several days on the open wharf, with consequent risk of loss or damage pending the granting of the permits; that no such restrictions are placed on cargoes arriving by Japanese vessels; and whether he will indicate to the Japanese Government that, unless the restrictions on British trade are removed, it may be necessary to impose similar restrictions on Japanese vessels arriving in British ports?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
The answer to the first two parts of the question is in the affirmative. Discrimination exists in so far as warehouse accommodation is made available for Japanese ships but not yet for British vessels. The matter has been taken up with the local Japanese authorities at Tsingtao and representations have been made by His Majesty's Ambassador at Tokyo pressing for the allocation of a further berth and/or reasonable warehouse space.
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
I hope as short a time as possible.
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
I trust that we shall get a reply as soon as possible.
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
We have said that we desire an early reply.
Mr Harry Day
, Southwark Central
asked the Prime Minister whether he will give particulars of the reply received from the Japanese Government to the communication addressed to them by His Majesty's Government relative to the steps that are being taken to safeguard British trade in respect of currency circulated in the Nanking district, which traders generally do not recognise?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
As the reply is rather long, I will, with permission, circulate it in the Official Report.
Mr Harry Day
, Southwark Central
Can the right hon. Gentleman say whether this currency is accepted as legal tender?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
I would refer the hon. Member to the statement which I propose to circulate.
"The Huahsing Commercial Bank.
Mr Harry Day
, Southwark Central
asked the Prime Minister particulars of the report called for by His Majesty's Government on the fact that the Japanese are endeavouring to create a Japanese monopoly in the trade affecting raw cotton in and around the area of Shanghai?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
I would refer the hon. Member to the answer given to my hon. Friend the Member for Salford, South (Mr. Stourton) on 20th December.
Mr Harry Day
, Southwark Central
In view of that statement may I ask whether the Government are taking any further action?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
In view of the fact that some time has elapsed, my Noble Friend is making further inquiries.
Mr John Banfield
, Wednesbury
asked the Prime Minister if he will satisfy himself that the Japanese, not having declared war against China, are under international law not justified in claiming the right to blockade Chinese ports and make representations to Japan accordingly?
Mr. David Adams:
asked the Prime Minister whether the Japanese are claiming to institute a blockade of Chinese ports; and whether, in that case, we recognise the existence of blockade?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
Shortly after the outbreak of hostilities between China and Japan in 1937, the Japanese Government purported to declare a blockade of the whole coast of China, which, however, they stated would be applied exclusively to Chinese vessels. Any attempt to apply such a blockade to the vessels of third Powers would constitute an assertion of belligerent rights and would, in the absence of a state of war between China and Japan, be illegal. His Majesty's Government have already made their views on this matter clear to the Japanese Government.
Mr John Morgan
, Doncaster
Do the Government regard the incident of the "Ranpura" as closed on the explanation given by the Japanese Government that they were mistaken as to the identity of the vessel?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
We have agreed that our ships may be boarded in case of genuine doubt as to whether a ship is a British ship or not. In the case of the "Ranpura," there could be no doubt whatever. Therefore, we took up a definite attitude and have now received an explanation from the Japanese Government that they made a mistake.
Mr John Morgan
, Doncaster
Is that regarded by the Government as a satisfactory explanation?
Mr R.A. Butler
, Saffron Walden
Yes, Sir, so far as it goes.
Laws are the rules by which a country is governed. Britain has a long history of law making and the laws of this country can be divided into three types:- 1) Statute Laws are the laws that have been made by Parliament. 2) Case Law is law that has been established from cases tried in the courts - the laws arise from test cases. The result of the test case creates a precedent on which future cases are judged. 3) Common Law is a part of English Law, which has not come from Parliament. It consists of rules of law which have developed from customs or judgements made in courts over hundreds of years. For example until 1861 Parliament had never passed a law saying that murder was an offence. From the earliest times courts had judged that murder was a crime so there was no need to make a law.