Provision of Meals or Milk (Circular).

Oral Answers to Questions — Education. – in the House of Commons at on 15 November 1934.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Miss Eleanor Rathbone Miss Eleanor Rathbone , Combined English Universities

15.

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Education whether he will consider with- drawing the restriction placed by Circular 1437 upon the freedom of local authorities to give milk or meals free to children on account of their parents' poverty without first requiring a medical inspection, in view of the dissatisfaction it has aroused and of the acknowledged difficulty of detecting the early signs of malnutrition?

Photo of Mr Herwald Ramsbotham Mr Herwald Ramsbotham , Lancaster

My Noble Friend is not prepared to withdraw the Circular. He is satisfied that medical selection on the lines indicated in the Circular affords the best means of securing that those children who need food or milk in fact get it, and that under any system other than that of medical selection there is a danger of overlooking children who require attention. He attaches the highest importance to a close study of defective nutrition and its treatment, and he regards it as in every way advantageous that this part of the work of the school medical service should be closely linked with the arrangements for the provision of meals and milk.

Photo of Miss Eleanor Rathbone Miss Eleanor Rathbone , Combined English Universities

Is the hon. Member aware that the organ of the local education authorities has condemned this restriction on their freedom, and are not local authorities the best judges of what should be done in this matter?

Photo of Mr Rhys Davies Mr Rhys Davies , Westhoughton

Is it not much better to prevent children becoming ill rather than to deal with them after they are ill?

Photo of Mr Herwald Ramsbotham Mr Herwald Ramsbotham , Lancaster

I think the system of medical inspection is much the best way of doing that.