Overpayments (Refund).

Oral Answers to Questions — Naval and Military Pensions and Grants. – in the House of Commons on 19th April 1923.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mr Alfred Short Mr Alfred Short , Wednesbury


asked the Minister of Pensions the number of cases in which pensioners have to make refunds due to mistakes; the amount of the money so involved; and the number due to error on the part of the Ministry and the applicants, respectively?

Photo of Sir Edwin Stockton Sir Edwin Stockton , Manchester Exchange


asked the Minister of Pensions if, taking the various weeks since the beginning of the current year, he will state in each case the total amount received through refunds from pensioners or ex-pensioners; and what is the average amount per person paid in each of the same periods?

Photo of Mr George Tryon Mr George Tryon , Brighton

I regret that the statistics of my Department are not kept in a form that would enable the information asked for to he readily obtained. I may, however, say that the bulk of the deductions made are in respect of advances granted on the express understanding that they would be recovered if pension was ultimately awarded. With regard to deductions in respect of over-issue of pension, I would like to take this opportunity of informing the hon. Members, and the House generally, that further substantial concessions in the matter have been agreed to. In future, where the over-issue is not brought to the notice of the recipient within 12 months and he could not reasonably be expected to have been aware of the overpayment, recovery will ordinarily be waived, and in other cases recovery will be limited to the amount actually overpaid during the last 12 months of the over-issue. When severe hardship would be occasioned, recovery may be waived on that ground. These concessions will be applied in principle to cases where recovery is already in progress, but they will not, of course, apply to cases of fraud or misrepresentation.

Photo of Mr Alfred Short Mr Alfred Short , Wednesbury

Can the right hon. Gentleman say whether the conditions which he has enumerated were not in operation in the lifetime of the last Ministry?

Photo of Mr George Tryon Mr George Tryon , Brighton

Some of them were. There were undoubtedly cases where hardship had arisen in which repayment was remitted. The complete adoption of the one-year limit has only been fully carried through recently. It was started before, and now it is completed.

Photo of Mr James Remnant Mr James Remnant , Holborn

In cases where money has been repaid in respect of overpayment, will there be a refund?

Photo of Mr George Tryon Mr George Tryon , Brighton

No, Sir. I could not agree that money which should never have been paid by us in the first instance should be once more paid to the pensioner.

Photo of Mr John Muir Mr John Muir , Glasgow Maryhill

Will the Minister consider the advisability, where repayment has to be made, of seeing that the pensioner receives the major portion of the payment instead of the minor portion, as is very often done now?

Photo of Mr George Tryon Mr George Tryon , Brighton

We have often arranged for recovery at a lower rate. I realise the hon. Member's point.