Clause 18. — (Declaration as to ss. 43 and 44 of 8 & 9 Geo. 5. c. 40.)

Part of Part II. – in the House of Commons at on 16 June 1921.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mr Archibald Williamson Mr Archibald Williamson , Moray and Nairnshire

The facts are pretty well in the possession of the Committee. The Mover of the Amendment placed the case before the House with great ability and clearness. The facts of the case are that the Government made a mistake: It allowed a Bill to go through and to become an Act which did not carry out its intentions, and the Government now comes to the House and says, "We wish you to help us to deprive the taxpayer of an advantage which we have accidentally given to him." That is really the position, and is it just or right? Is it the position of the taxpayer when the mistake is against him and not in his favour? No leniency is shown then. He is told it is very unfortunate, but that it is the law and the injustice must be suffered.