Policing and Crime Bill
12:00 pm

Julie Kirkbride (Bromsgrove, Conservative)
I have concerns about the phrase controlled for gain because, from what we have heard in previous evidence, there will be circumstances in which women in a brothel would be happy with that arrangement, because it is a safer way of operating their trade. Technically, they are in control of the gain, because there is someone there answering the telephone and sorting it all out. So, while the Governments intention to tackle trafficking is entirely laudable and desirable, the catch-all controlled for gain will be more likely to attack or cause a problem for the better forms or organisation of prostitution. Is there another phrase that could be used, Mr. Lodder, other than controlled for gain, which could get the traffickers rather than the blanket?
