Clause 68 - Appeals
Criminal Justice Bill
3:45 pm
Mr Dominic Grieve (Beaconsfield, Conservative)
The hon. and learned Lady makes an interesting point. I had assumed that an appeal was to be only on a point of law, the same as any other appeal to the House of Lords. In view of the nature of such applications to the Court of Appeal, there would be few occasions on which one went to the House of Lords, as most require a reconsideration of the facts. However, there may be occasions when the interpretation placed by the Court of Appeal on the facts that might allow a retrial could lead to those who represented the acquitted person to argue that the rules set down in clauses 65 and 66 were not being followed, and that they wanted a legal ruling on the point. That is how I assumed the matter would proceed.