Recent comments

Most recent annotations on things by Andrew Robathan

  • Maha Aldoujaily: "Almost as soon as British troops appeared morale collapsed and they surrendered" This statement is based on ignorance. Iraq's troops were all conscripts with no choice, talking about morale... (7 June 2009)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Stephen Walkley: Does Mr Robathan know what is going on? In his own Constituency Lutterworth has exactly the same Market Charter. (9 October 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Tim Ambler: Mr Robathan An excellent speech. Thank you. As you rightly said, bats have become a nightmare here in Norfolk due to the absurd requirements of the Government quangos covering these matters.... (1 July 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Noel Jackson: Why is it ridiculous that you can get fined large sums of money for disturbing bats. All spoecies are rare and are internationally recognized as needing protection? Mr Robotham needs to explain... (23 May 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Chris Walker: The SNP gathered more votes than any other party in the chamber in both the list and constituency votes. That is why they are in government. For the member to suggest that the voting system... (11 May 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Daniel Watkins: Noel, He doesn't state that all bat protection legislation is foolish. Rather, he states that he doesn't want the process to be inhibited by those elements of bat protection legislation that... (22 March 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Noel Jackson: Why does Andrew Robathan consider bat protection legislation foolish. he says he wants to protect bats but does he assume that this can be done without laws? Its seems a very strange position... (21 March 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Edward Betts: This is the part of Hansard being referenced: http://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?i d=2008-03-12a.299.1#g299.4 (14 March 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Paul Peros: While I disagree that a referendum is necessary, and find that in general those who insist on a referendum, such as Andrew Robathan MP, are not as upset about defending democracy as they suggest,... (21 February 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Peter Slee: I find it chilling that Matthew Engel - in the same article - also says this: "Until the late 1980s, it was assumed that the Soviet bloc would go on forever getting bigger and more powerful. But... (21 February 2008)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Frederick Clark: I shall add that Mr Robathan's party is the only party currently represented in the HOC that has not betrayed the British people by breaking its promise. On the eve of the 2005 election the 3... (28 November 2007)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Mark Bestford: Well said Susan. As someone who used to shoot as a hobby I can tell you that weapons are not just for "killing people". They are also for hunting, pest control and for sport. Some are... (21 June 2007)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Susan Kirby: The constituent is 63, is a collector only, and never used the guns. He was jailed for 5 years for owning them without a licence. Compare that to a case reported on the same day, where a man... (21 June 2007)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Stephen Walkley: Sorry not seen anythıng about this case but why is the MP defendıng anyone having hand guns. Hand guns are for killing people. (20 June 2007)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Susan Kirby: "These are not our people"? An odd thing to quote if it was not said, so could Mr. Robathan please clarify what exactly was said which led him to believe the Chancellor said this? Thank you in... (11 May 2007)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • david collins: I quite agree this THE RH A ROBATHAN. Double standards in the commons and for the public do seem to be evident and give politicians a generic bad name. D. COLLINS (30 September 2006)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Chris Turner: I'm not sure five cleaners count as "civil servants", nor an "often" encounter. (13 June 2006)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Tori Siegler: I would ask in reply to that whether Sir feels that taxis are accessible for every wheelchair user. (10 May 2006)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Tori Siegler: I believe that to use the term 'normal' is to greatly overlook the fact that there is no true definition of the word. Therefore what makes someone with a disability 'abnormal'? (10 May 2006)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Awale kullane: The hon. Gentleman MP Andrew Robathan I am a somali who believes in the unity of somalia. I have fled the war and would like to highlight anotherside of the somali conflict, as you support part... (12 December 2005)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • pete marrable: We do not know better than most parents. We should not pretend that we do. The nugget of gold in this debate; leaving no possible rebutal if you agree with it. (3 November 2004)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • pete marrable: If you believe in empirical evidence then the case for RE-introducing corporal punishment is un-assaleable. However those who dream up these ideas do not seem to believe in using evidence to... (3 November 2004)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Gregory Block: (That information, along with other information provided on the ballot, can make it impossible to forge someone else's ballot paper) (6 July 2004)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Gregory Block: A one way hash would allow the people who generated the numbers to know which address corresponds to the number on the ballot without it being apparent/public, or for that matter, crackable and... (6 July 2004)
    Read annotation | All by this user
  • Chris Lightfoot: Umm... ballot papers in this country are specifically intended to record each voter's vote, so that in the event of a dispute, an election can be properly audited. Postal ballots are not... (5 July 2004)
    Read annotation | All by this user